To be honest this game isn't that bad. It's decent, but of course hardcore fans from the Thief franchise will feel disappointed for several reasons. My main complain is the world and level design, because it is an 'open world' you think this could benefit a game like Thief where you have a lot of freedom and the exploration feels great, but the truth is that with exception of some missions, everything feels uninteresting, the places you can go are very limited and there are some nice puzzles from time to time but still don't feel that's enough. I feel a problem that they didn't solve from the previous Thief 3 is the lack of any fast traveling. While at first everything feels exciting to explore and discover, trying to always traverse throught the places avoiding enemies can feel tedious. Despite of all that, I still bought this game after playing it on Steam and I feel happy to own the full collection.
A pity that this game never got the remaster treatment other LucasArts games got. This might be the most complex Point and Click ever made. Not only the story and gameplay are excellent. I think most Point and Click games suffers from being too lineal, so if you already finished the game once, it was probably the end, there was not point on replaying except if there were multiple endings. But this game, put multiple paths based on your choices that alters dramatically the story, also it randomized some puzzles so if you replayed the game, some objects you were looking for were hidden in another room, or different objects being required to solve a certain puzzle. I don't think I've seen before those kind of elements in a different game from the same genre. The game also features multiple endings, however this game also features deaths, which some people may dislike in these kind of games. I think this game is totally underrated if you compare to other games by LucasArts, definitely worth playing.
If you haven't played Finding Paradise before, even if you played To the Moon before, I strongly recommend to firstly play the game. As always, great music, emotive storytelling, even some clever humor in there, this time the game is only an hour long, it's just a very simple and lineal game, practically no gameplay, I think some people will find it cute but not so interesting but everything starts to make more sense once you finished playing Finding Paradise, since it works as the prequel to that game, I think you can play this game before Finding Paradise, but I think it's better to play this game to explore a little more the events from its sequel.
