Most of these negative reviews seem to be just a reaction to Spiderweb trying something new. Yes, you have to finish each dungeon in one go, without retreating, in order to gain XP. Yes the monsters respawn if you leave and come back. This actually makes the game far more challenging! You can't just spam fireballs and healing potions and then run back to town. Combat is highly tactical. Resources are limited. The character development is actually far more complex than it appears and the game world is surprisingly rich. The story is highly political and involves ethical decision making. I've put many, many hours into Avernum but I might like this game even more. Queen's Wish is a totally unique RPG and I love it!
