I was going to give it two stars but decided to grade on a curve of other recent games and gave it an extra star. It starts off quite good and for a little bit its quite entertaining, however, about halfway through the game it goes downhill and I didn't like the ending.
For one thing I did not really think the three paths were very different from each other. If you want a game that really offered three very different paths you should play Quest for Glory, which Atlantis obviously owes quite a bit to. Another was the beginning was terrific however I felt the bulk of the game was quite lonely, being almost entirely wandering around a cave and looking for orichalum. As for the Indy Points, I never understood at all what that was about. But still a good game from LucasArts, but I don't think I would ever play it again.