It's a good game, no doubt about that. It has a charming humor, the good nostalgia flair, the right amount of meta-humor and fourth-wall-breaking and the puzzles are mostly well done. Of course, your mileage may vary, it depends on how much you enjoy such humor. Personally, I found it a little bit on the short side for that price (under 10 hours for me), which is what makes me give it 4 stars instead of 5. A few hours more gameplay or a few bucks less would have made the mixture perfect. But if you enjoyed the old Lucasarts adventures, you will very likely enjoy this game, too.
