First, I give it 3/5 but I don't mean it as a bad way (where, nowadays, anything below 8/10 or 4/5 is bad). YL is the perfect example of a "good enough" game. The game is perfectly playable, has some charm, and will last you a solid 10-15 hours. But ultimately, it's all there is to it. you're unlikely to be struck in awe by anything in the game. It's worth playing, you'll have a good time for sure, but it certainly won't be anybody's GOTY, and it shouldn't be.
A mediocre, abandoned game. I backed it on Kickstarter, lured in by the promises of a good game, and was fooled, like many. I waited all this time, after trying it just after release, hoping they'd patch it because it was barely playable. then I simply forgot about it. Over a year later, I discovered it again. it is abandoned. no updates, no fixes. Don't bother.