The story and atmospherics are excellent but there are a lot of flaws. Some of the quests hinge on others being done first with no indication. You get encouraged to learn about NPCs to give max XP for embracing them then they can disappear wasting the effort The attack skill controls feel very mushy in combat with slow response times You get spawned into the middle of multiple packs of enemies occasionally after a death The camera in combat gets too close sometimes so you can't see what's going on. TL;DR - Artistically excellent, mechanically flawed
