I'm in the third Chapter and so far it's really good. The riddles are on the light side, but that's just what I like at the moment. The atmosphere is really dense and cosy. With a nice mystery sprinkelt in. Only the humor (german version) does not work so good. But it's not so bad that it distracting. Overall a thumbs up from an oldschool Lucasarts adventure fan.
I like this game! Ok, I can understand why so many people are disapointed. When it (finally) arrived it was painfully buggy, had a bad performance and it was nothing like the developer had promised years before. But it has it's own charme. I started my Ultima-career late with Ultima 8 and I loved it for what it was, because I didn't had this expectations longtime Ultima-veterans had. And it's the same with Ultima 9. It feels and plays alot like the first Gothic just from the opposite side of the morale scale and without the dirty talk. If you just take it as a big and rich world to explore with plenty of wonderous places and characters you will have a great time playing this game! It may be no great Ultima but is has it's own virtues and isn't Ultima all about discovering your own virtues?!