I've played this game multiple times and beat it, and I still enjoy it. The story is original and brilliant, and the graphics aren't bad either (for a game of the 90's). The voices weren't awful, in fact, they were bearable. That doesn't take away from it though. The atmosphere is haunting and very surreal, and it's a game I actually own on my game shelf because it is a gem.
I got this game back in high school, and even though I had a bit of trouble with it back then, it was awesome. I love the story and the gameplay, and everything about it was just perfect. I still have the disks in their case, I've just misplaced the small box (I bought it at Wal Mart in one of the $10.00 slots).