It's is skyrim.
It's either so bad it's good or it's so good it's bad and after one billion hours in this game, I'm still not sure which is the right answer.
It's cliche, but they simply don't write games like this anymore. The mechanics are most defintely clunky, but the experience, story, intricay of it all overshadows any kind of drawbacks. Unironic 10/10.