Disclaimer: Based on Steam version Comparing to Gothic 2, it might be 3.5/5. Comparing to basically any other RPG? Clear 5/5. Game might be a little hard for players used to Skyrim, but I promise you, the game is very rewarding, you only have to make yourself immerse in it. Don't try to game the systems, just pretend that you actually ARE in the world: Can't find quest location? Ask around for directions. Can't beat enemy? You need to become stronger. How do you become stronger? Level up and train your strength or weapon skill, find better armor, find better weapon... I believe this is the correct way to start with Piranha Bytes games as the graphic is acceptable (comparing to their masterpieces - Gothic 2 and Gothic 1). If you enjoy the game, please buy Gothic 2 and try to play mod "Archolos", it is similar, yet superior game to Risen in every aspect but graphics and control.
Finished Jade Empire three times a few years ago and now I am addicted again. Apart from Gothic I+II, this game has the best atmosphere I ve seen so far. Setting is clearly oriental, but has nothing to do with anime (dont get me wrong, I love anime style), it is more like classic kung fu movies. Yes, combat can be boring if you dont experiment with styles and harmonic combos, but I love the way there is no warrior/mage/thief and you are rewarded for using everything you have - weapons, magic, fists or even tranformation into demons. Story is great and I was literary cought off guard a few times, even though many people will surely find the plot predictable. And there are some great side quests you dont want to miss. Seriously, if you like RPGs, fighting, good stories, chinese culture, or even one of these things, just grab the game for that price and give it a chance. One of the biggest advantage of Jade Empire is that it is quite unique and you will find no such experience in any other game.