Posted on: January 26, 2025

Revue de l'accès anticipé

Ivan__tacko

Jeux: 47 Avis: 11

Unbalanced and lacking content

This game is in development but already costs $30 so I am reviewing it as a full game: Not much content for the price - 3 very similar scenarios, 3 maps, no campaign mode, scenarios are basically a sandbox with an optional goal that you may or may not pursue. Many features are still missing, such as most of the development tree. Beside that, the game seems to me very unbalanced: Imaginary outlaws stealing all your tools in the first few months of playing, when you don't have a realistic way to prevent that. New families not wanting to move in to your village first several months because you had homelessness in the beginning - again something you can't avoid. Then you can't upgrade a burgage from tier 2 to 3 because there isn't enough food variety despite there being 4 different types of food in the nearby food stall, or you can't upgrade because the local church is randomly not serving some of the few houses built around it. Granary workers building two stalls in one marketplace instead of building one stall in each of the two marketplaces. And my absolute favorite: granary workers refusing to stock more than 2 types of food in the food stall despite there being 5 types of food in the granary, preventing you from upgrading burgages - so you have to demolish the stall and let them rebuild it. Despite all that, the game is somewhat fun and has a lot of potential. It just desperately needs more work.

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: June 11, 2024

Revue de l'accès anticipé

DJMorpheus2007

Possesseur vérifié

Jeux: 349 Avis: 35

Love It So Far

Clearly, with this being Early Access, it's not going to be perfect, nobody should expect that, but I was honestly surprised by how good this game is, can't wait for the full release. Understandably, it does have some issues and some things aren't finished yet (WiP), but the makings of an amazing game are already in-place. I marked it as 4 stars, because it's not quite there yet and the Accessibility Options have caused me a few problems. Not having great sight anymore, I LOVE that the UI can be scaled, however... I cannot scale it above 1.2, or things start disappearing off-screen. I can just about manage with 1.2 scaling, so it's not a huge issue for me, just thought it best to point it out in case others have similar issues :-). Overall, even with th unfinished game and the issues, I'm hooked. So glad I decided to invest in this game, looking forward to seeing it fully-realised :-).

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: February 2, 2025

Revue de l'accès anticipé

JuJuCicoMS

Possesseur vérifié

Jeux: 1 Avis: 1

Super, dans le contexte

Super pour un jeu fait par 1 seule personne. Il faut parier sur le fait que la version définitive sera magnifique.

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: April 27, 2025

Revue de l'accès anticipé

dshiokawa

Possesseur vérifié

Jeux: 31 Avis: 1

[Early Access] My Review

I'm still learning how the game works, but I'm loving the game so far. The attention to detail is amazing in this game. The sound design, the game's atmosphere, pacing, what you can and cannot do, settlement progression... Everything seems carefully tuned to express the feeling of being in the medieval era. But here goes a few of my constructive criticisms: - Work a bit on the family's npc collision (sometimes the family member stays still just because there are other npcs in the construction area); - "Where is the lord?" Having ourselves as the lord wandering around the village/settlement giving orders or just managing would be a nice touch; - Family "join likelyhood indicator"? The approval system is cool, but we never know when a new family is coming; - Construction lot improvement for the homes. If by mistake, I forgot to designate a place for the courtyard, I have to destroy the whole house and redefine the lot and rebuild it from scratch again. Having a button to "add" a courtyard for an existing home would be nice;

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Posted on: June 21, 2025

zaktheevil

Jeux: Avis: 2

Beautiful and chill but too incomplete

The game is amazing for what it is and has massive potential but it's very early in development and the progress is glacial: it's been 7 years and it'll likely be another 3-5 years before it's done. I got it at a huge discount so not complaining, but it's not worth the full price. The game is enjoyable and playable though, it has certain charm, it's very chill and you can get lost in it for hours, I played daily for a week but it is incomplete and very far from being done: seems unbalanced and features and elements are missing: skill tree is incomplete, for instance, and many mechanisms are very finicky, like trade, which results in significant frustration, lacks content too and the UI is glitchy. The help is barebones and missing most information, you have to figure out a lot by trial and error. The peaceful mode needs some re-balance as it's tedious to progress without combat The game is excruciatingly slow, I can't play it at x1, I'd lose all interest in it. When playing at x4 or x12 it runs into massive CPU bottlenecks though (not graphics issue) if your town gets big: bad stutter and very low FPS. The ugliest aspect of this game: when you acquire a new region, you start all over, from scratch, even your skill tree resets to nothing, you can't move resources or people in any meaningful way. This is very demotivating and discouraging and makes no sense. Why do I need to barter between my own lands? It makes no sense. Also, barter is weird and possibly broken: you can't set the amount to barter, so it will drain the resource from one region and other times it doesn't work at all. This needs to change. I think I'm done with it for now and will wait for an update. Whenever that might be :)

Trouvez-vous ce commentaire utile ?

Découvrez les jeux de CD PROJEKT RED

Ne manquez pas

Featured

Proche, mais pas une correspondance exacte

Manor Lords

Autres notes

Ajouter un avis

Modifier un avis

Supprimer cet avis ?

Signaler cet avis

Informations complémentaires (obligatoire) :

Signaler cet avis