So, I've tried unplugging my controller and restarting and my guy is still constantly moving backwards. This happens on no other game. Anybody know a fix?

What do you mean by "moving backwards"? The sprites in early Ultima games have no facing.

Alternatively, perhaps you could mention which game you are talking about, as this particular subforum covers an entire (rather large) series of games.

Sorry for the trouble. I had a usb charger plugged in, it's fixed.