prottenstein: Sorry, mate, but I don't understand your rant.
About dropping the potions, you are right. It's the player lacking attention.
About the cards of the innkeeper there's no way to know in advance they will disappear. When I make my choices in each dialogue I pay a lot of attention to them. I won't reload to make another choice.
But at the end of the prologue you are forced. If there was the possibility to change the story I'd be with you, but this case is similar to Letho winning after being beaten like hell in TW2
Oh, mostly I was ranting about the failure to read the tutorial for the new alchemy design. I guess I could have separated my thoughts a little better. The card issue I simply view as "Oh, I missed it. I'll catch it next time," where several people here feel it's a bigger issue. The two are not connected, I apologize for the lack of clarity!
EDIT
prottenstein: Then perhaps, a notice could have helped :)
All right, I've been converted: MAYBE they should have made these cards available elsewhere after she left her business in White Orchard. Realistically, would she not have sold them to someone else that maybe you could have played again and earned from? Or sold them to another merchant you could have bought them from? I agree on this front now. Disregard my assault on the "card complainers" ;)
However, my rant against failure to read tutorials is still in full swing.