GODzillaGSPB: Simple: It depends on the controller. And on the driver / software for that controller. And maybe even on the windows version using this driver. ;) Computers configurations...they're all different you see. :D
But I didn't ask why it does work for one player and not for the other, but why one game makes it work and not the other. There's a difference.
I am currently playing a game that works just perfectly in that regard, you can use both methods at the same time, the game registers
everything. But on the other side, this game doesn't even know
which league of it's own TW2 is in, it doesn't even
register in the same universe. So yes, I do see that we have to trade some functionality for the great complexity of TW2. But I can still hope that they might make an effort to work this out - after they tended to the more pressing matters. After all, they can't really release it to console with the flaws the controller controls still have. And they do want to learn and evolve, get even better, not rest on their laurels. At least I hope they do.
And about the USB-Hub: I just meant that a hub makes it easier to plug and unplug controllers.
Yeah, I got that. And kind of jokingly informed you that I'm a front plugger. ;)
And that I don't want to unplug, because I play with the controller.