wolfenspiel: I still own the ORIGINAL board game, when it was just a one-off among a shelf full of board games and games with hexagon mats for battles, yes bought back in 1983 or so....in fact I had no idea of any expansions, as I guess it really didn't become popular here in Erie PA. The original game takes about an hour or so to play, and while fun, really isn't anything to write home about. In fact, the way it was designed is rather cheap...
If you had the first edition, then that would have had black-and-white artwork. I picked up the second edition (essentially the same but with colourised artwork). Also managed to get all the expansions for it (Talisman Expansion Set, Talisman the Adventure, Talisman Dungeon, Talisman Timescape, Talisman City, Talisman Dragons) which did greatly expand the scope of the game (I do recall playing one 4-hour session with 3 others).
wolfenspiel: Truth be told, one would think after "30 years of content", instead of a shit-ton of DLC, they would have been able to create one single World of Talisman game by now, incorperating the best of all the content, what "worked", while discarding what "didn't work", was unpopular, or broke the game mechanics.
In fairness, the base game has been refined (the Fate mechanic, making mules and horse-and-carts Followers rather than Objects) and some of the add-on boards are quite good (though quite different from the original expansion sets). The boardgame wasn't under continuous development though (Games Workshop did several other boardgames and shifted their development focus onto the Warhammer games due to the greater potential for addons).
wolfenspiel: ...I looked into the game seriously, as for the intro price it seemed a great deal, a bit of nostalgia and a new way to play a game I already own....until I saw the amount and price of DLC, and that the "entire set" would cost upwards of $100, for a simple board game...
Agreed - this needs serious discounting to be worthwhile (having said that, I managed to pick up the base game for $1.74 and the DLC pack for $25). The physical boardgame (and expansions) are now
seriously expensive ($250!) - quite likely due to the miniatures included (the original game used cardboard standups for each character).
wolfenspiel: Is the digital game worth it? It MIGHT be, but I wouldn't waste money or time buying DLC until they change the packaging, and make it less of a cash drain. There's too many other games out there that already do that...
Compared to the non-discountable (short of a lucky find in a thrift store) physical game, the basic set is quite reasonable and gets discounted relatively frequently. You also have the computer doing a lot of the donkey work (which can mount up when you bring all the expansions into play - Destiny Cards, Day/Night cycles, Reaper/Werewolf/Harbinger movement, Dragon scales) and skip out on the setting up and tidying up afterwards.
On the other hand, you lose out on all the tactile fun of moving pieces around - gaming online doesn't match up to gloating in person when someone else gets turned into a Toad and a good chunk of the (non-bundled) DLC is just taking the mickey (Single character cards? Legendary decks to toughen up a game made too easy by other expansions?). Really there should be a bundle including
all the DLC - and revised offline installers so you
don't have to run through every single effing-one of DLC just to get an update to the base game (for those unaware, the base game download includes all the data for all the expansions - each expansion DLC just "enables" it).