It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
@Mark Y.

The time has come, after hearing so many good things about it, to play Primordia. Well, downloading from GOG, I discovered that you have written a novella accompanying Primordia, and couldn't help to start reading it immediately.

The story arc is brilliant and the time jumps perfectly lead the reader to grasp the growing scope. McIlven's heroics express exceptionally well the mind of a people who wish for atonement.

As good as it is, I realize now how much superior a medium the Meres are. Even if you go fully linear, the way the story and art blends cannot be touched by a pdf.

Kudos for researching and characterizing the logic of robots. Not many writers can do that much better, though the late Iain M. Banks' Excession comes to mind.

I see that your writing of Inifere was not so much characterizing madness, but rather a way of describing a different way of interfacing with reality, similar to how the robots of Fallen have a different way of interpreting their world. But I will maintain that embracing madness in a world out of balance is the way to feel secure in your search for the truth. Autonomous 8 gains in the end because it changed, and McIlven's heroics are so much beyond a normal approach that sanity appears overrated. You have to question it continuously to arrive at the solutions required.

I am looking forward to discover Primordia!
Thanks for the kind words! A few thoughts below.
avatar
Quantomas: As good as it is, I realize now how much superior a medium the Meres are. Even if you go fully linear, the way the story and art blends cannot be touched by a pdf.
Probably, but the Meres took much longer to write! I can't remember exactly how long "Fallen" took, but I want to say that the average Mere was something like 50 hours?
Kudos for researching and characterizing the logic of robots. Not many writers can do that much better, though the late Iain M. Banks' Excession comes to mind.
To even be mentioned in the same sentence with him seems like an unworthy honor. :)
I will maintain that embracing madness in a world out of balance is the way to feel secure in your search for the truth.
Madness is one of the ways of coping with the disconnect between the world-as-it-is and the world-as-it-should-be. Primordia is very much about such coping mechanisms, so I'm hopeful you'll find it engaging. (Here are some thoughts I wrote on the subject: http://whatever.scalzi.com/2012/12/05/the-big-idea-mark-yohalem/)
avatar
WormwoodStudios: Madness is one of the ways of coping with the disconnect between the world-as-it-is and the world-as-it-should-be.
Yes. Between the the world-as-it-is and the world-as-it-should-be is the world-how-you-perceive-it. If there is no disconnect, your roles are defined and you can live freely like a bird in its natural environment.

If your perceptions do not match the reality, sanity is a poor guide to judge the merit of your actions, it is like a cage. If you embrace madness — or should I say rather ditch the pretense of sanity — the map is redrawn and you can question everything. Eventually you realize that the only way to gain freedom is the truth.

Your protagonists know that. Inifere, McIlven and Autonomous 8 in the end.
- I read this the first time we met. It is still as great as the first time I read it.

Your aunt Virginia knew about this disconnect, obviously. If I interpret her work correctly, she was critical about how people always shove the reality away. People perceive it as sane to raise kids, enjoy themselves, and help themselves to all kinds of things the world has on offer. But at the same time their actions sustain and empower a system that is anything but human, whether it is using the threat of nuclear holocaust as a tool or being oblivious to the wholesale destruction of what sustains life in a never-ending cycle of greed.

People know of this disconnect, surely. The human being, technically any creative intelligence, has the remarkable skill to adapt. But its true power will only be unlocked if you question your sanity and embrace the gulf between the world-as-it-is and the world-as-it-should-be.

No amount of adjusting your perspective will do, it will only happen if you learn to change yourself.

Now to Primordia!
Post edited August 02, 2017 by Quantomas
I can barely remember what I had for breakfast, let alone my Internet conversations! :) I was able to eventually place your name from the inXile forums, but I couldn't really remember much of the content of our conversation there, other than a general recollection of being overawed by the brightness of your scrutiny. Hopefully it will find something worth scrutinizing in Primordia, too. :)