It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
This thread makes me want to look for my copy of Archives. Had a lot of fun with 1 and 6. Never liked 7 because of, you guessed it, that damn forest.
avatar
orcishgamer: There is abandonware, taking advantage of it isn't not copyright infringement, but abandonware has a definition and there are games that fall into that category.
avatar
Gundato: Arguable, but the term "abandonware" exists solely to provide an excuse to pirate stuff. And most of those have NOT been abandoned by their copyright holders.

I guess, the working term most folks understand is a title that has been unpublished for quite some time and not available for retail or planned to be so in the near term. Obviously titles can leave abandonware status if, for example, they become available on Steam or XBox Live Arcade or some such.
Is it a legitimate excuse to download the game without paying? Well, I can't make that decision for anyone. Can you violate copyright with abandonware, yes.
avatar
Gundato: Arguable, but the term "abandonware" exists solely to provide an excuse to pirate stuff. And most of those have NOT been abandoned by their copyright holders.
avatar
orcishgamer: I guess, the working term most folks understand is a title that has been unpublished for quite some time and not available for retail or planned to be so in the near term. Obviously titles can leave abandonware status if, for example, they become available on Steam or XBox Live Arcade or some such.
Is it a legitimate excuse to download the game without paying? Well, I can't make that decision for anyone. Can you violate copyright with abandonware, yes.

Except that most of the "abandonware" titles are still readily available on Amazon and the like, let alone eBay.
avatar
orcishgamer: I guess, the working term most folks understand is a title that has been unpublished for quite some time and not available for retail or planned to be so in the near term. Obviously titles can leave abandonware status if, for example, they become available on Steam or XBox Live Arcade or some such.
Is it a legitimate excuse to download the game without paying? Well, I can't make that decision for anyone. Can you violate copyright with abandonware, yes.
avatar
Gundato: Except that most of the "abandonware" titles are still readily available on Amazon and the like, let alone eBay.

If it's available from an actual copyright holder or their agent on Amazon then of course it's not abandonware, if it's only available second hand then it still probably is. Just because someone can buy a used copy of Final Fantasy 3 for 400 dollars doesn't mean it's generally available (I have no idea if that's the going rate for a copy of that game, btw, it's just an example of an old semi-valuable title that I don't believe is available for purchase from the copyright holder or their agents).
Actual abandonware == games you can't buy from the copyright holder or their agent now nor in the near future; also generally excluding fairly recent games. Again, of course one can violate copyright with an abandonware game (which I think we agree on), though not all uses would necessarily be infringement.
I can't speak to what's on abandonware sites, if they have copies of games that are generally available by the copyright holder's agent in most areas of the world then I would argue they are including non-abandonware on their site.
avatar
Gundato: Except that most of the "abandonware" titles are still readily available on Amazon and the like, let alone eBay.
avatar
orcishgamer: If it's available from an actual copyright holder or their agent on Amazon then of course it's not abandonware, if it's only available second hand then it still probably is. Just because someone can buy a used copy of Final Fantasy 3 for 400 dollars doesn't mean it's generally available (I have no idea if that's the going rate for a copy of that game, btw, it's just an example of an old semi-valuable title that I don't believe is available for purchase from the copyright holder or their agents).
Actual abandonware == games you can't buy from the copyright holder or their agent now nor in the near future; also generally excluding fairly recent games. Again, of course one can violate copyright with an abandonware game (which I think we agree on), though not all uses would necessarily be infringement.
I can't speak to what's on abandonware sites, if they have copies of games that are generally available by the copyright holder's agent in most areas of the world then I would argue they are including non-abandonware on their site.

I am just going to speed things up:
Abandonware is a form of piracy. Simple enough.
Any form of "abandonware" is piracy. Any form of "warez" is piracy. I don't care how you justify that it deserves to be called "abandonware" instead of "warez". It is still piracy. And, by the letter of the law, it is piracy.
avatar
Gundato: I am just going to speed things up:
Abandonware is a form of piracy. Simple enough.
Any form of "abandonware" is piracy. Any form of "warez" is piracy. I don't care how you justify that it deserves to be called "abandonware" instead of "warez". It is still piracy. And, by the letter of the law, it is piracy.

This, there is nothing that says a copyright holder must distribute their intellectual property, so taking it without permission is piracy.
avatar
orcishgamer: There is abandonware, taking advantage of it isn't not copyright infringement, but abandonware has a definition and there are games that fall into that category.
avatar
Gundato: Arguable, but the term "abandonware" exists solely to provide an excuse to pirate stuff. And most of those have NOT been abandoned by their copyright holders.

If the stores dont have the games, and you cant buy it from the developers site, and no online distributors have it..... i consider that abadonware.
Hey i want that 15 year old game that you guys made and still own the rights to. Where can i buy it? No where...torrenting it is.
back to wizardry. heard there is a PS3 version, but only in Japan. It looks like the PS2 version but man i love the artwork they did for it.
avatar
Gundato: Arguable, but the term "abandonware" exists solely to provide an excuse to pirate stuff. And most of those have NOT been abandoned by their copyright holders.
avatar
grove12345: If the stores dont have the games, and you cant buy it from the developers site, and no online distributors have it..... i consider that abadonware.
Hey i want that 15 year old game that you guys made and still own the rights to. Where can i buy it? No where...torrenting it is.
back to wizardry. heard there is a PS3 version, but only in Japan. It looks like the PS2 version but man i love the artwork they did for it.

So if Bansama can't buy a game because Japan hates the PC, he should pirate it? That overseas shipping is a bitch.
If I couldn't buy the original non-US version of The Witcher because I live in the land of awesomeness, should I have pirated it? That international shipping is a bitch.
Clearly, you think it is morally right. That isn't really the topic at hand. The point is: Abandonware does not exist. It is just a fancy term used so that pirates can pretend that what they are doing is legal. It isn't. It is still very illegal. Saying "it is okay because it is abandonware" is the same thing as "It is okay because the last game I bought wasn't worth full price" or "It is okay because I don't like the DRM model" or "It is okay because I will buy it when it is cheaper" or "it is okay because I can't afford this game (but I can afford a state of the art computer to play it with)"
So if you aren't going to go around praising people for downloading a Reloaded release rather than buying a game, please don't do it with "abandonware" either. Especially since many of the "abandonware" sites are pretty anti-GoG and anti-Steam and the like, simply because it takes away their justification for piracy.
Besides, like I said, most games worth playing* are still readily available on eBay and Amazon. And usually, at reasonable-ish prices (70 bucks for a 15 year old game isn't too bad, if you really want it).
* Yes, that is a very subjective title. But generally, anything that doesn't bomb miserably gets enough production runs that most retailers have a pretty large surplus left over. Even Planescape and Arcanum were pretty readily available for under 50 bucks prior to the semi-recent re-releases. Think I got Arcanum for 10 bucks in a GoGamer sale.
In fact, Amazon is selling the Ultimate WIzardry collection for 50 bucks (plus 4 dollars shipping) right now. And I am sure you could find it cheaper if you check eBay or a few other retailers.
Post edited September 06, 2010 by Gundato
Whoa now. Since I'm the one who brought up Wiz VII's "abandonware" status, let me see if I can clarify things. First off, you'll notice I didn't provide any links or affirmatively state that it was or wasn't abandonware, just that it is more widely available online than other entries in the series, for unclear reasons.
Second, that abandonware "exists" is, I would argue, self-evident. Legality doesn't enter into it. Whether one recognizes it as ethical or legitimate or not, that doesn't change the fact that it is a concept - a thing which exists in the world because enough people refer to it as such. For example, a bastard son of a medieval monarch might not have been a legitimate heir to the throne, but that doesn't change the fact that the son existed and was a living human being. A gay marriage might not yet be legally recognized in most of the United States, but you can bet a married gay couple from Massachusetts still considers themselves married when they visit Georgia. Abandonware exists, period. This is simply a semantic argument.
Also, let's put it this way: Some copyright holders allow their titles to become freeware or public domain, most often with no further support. I would consider this "freeware" to be a form of legal abandonware. You might insist on calling it freeware, but I think the key issue is availability and support. In addition, sometimes copyright ownership is ambiguous or unknown even to the companies that hold the rights themselves. It's pointless to argue about the ethics and morality of it, because we all have different standards - it's all about how you get through the night.
One can pay high prices to third-party sellers for old games which are far in excess of what contemporary games cost - money which, in all likelihood, will never go to the original creators of the game. One can download a game which is unlikely to be released in the near future, and thereby technically infringe on the rights of some holding company that doesn't care one way or another whether some IP they bought as part of a package deal 10 years and 5 CEOs ago is being "pirated" or not. It's all part of that grey area inherent to life.
I like GOG. I have no problem paying a nominal amount for old games. I think every form of media which can be transmitted digitally should be available for immediate download, for a reasonable fee, and with no strings attached. Eventually, that will probably be the case. In the meantime, I don't lose too much sleep over things like abandonware. If I really thought Wiz VII had been released to the public domain, I would have given a link - I just don't want people arguing further based on an offhand comment I made.
And please take no offense from my arguments about the existence of abandonware, either, Gundato. That's just how I view things. You're saying that it doesn't legally exist, and I'm saying that it doesn't have to be legally recognized to exist. We obviously both pay for games, let's call the whole thing off.
My favorite series of all-time. Actually played the original on an Apple IIE back in 1982 or 1983 I believe. I have the archives on CD and Wiz 8.
I might have to dig out these just 'cause I saw this thread. Blasphemy to you all ;) Hoping they will run on Win7 64-bit.
PS - I still have the original Clue Book for Crusaders of the Dark Savant. I have used it so much over the years it kinda looks like an old pirate map!
avatar
Bysshe: Whoa now. Since I'm the one who brought up Wiz VII's "abandonware" status, let me see if I can clarify things. First off, you'll notice I didn't provide any links or affirmatively state that it was or wasn't abandonware, just that it is more widely available online than other entries in the series, for unclear reasons.
Second, that abandonware "exists" is, I would argue, self-evident. Legality doesn't enter into it. Whether one recognizes it as ethical or legitimate or not, that doesn't change the fact that it is a concept - a thing which exists in the world because enough people refer to it as such. For example, a bastard son of a medieval monarch might not have been a legitimate heir to the throne, but that doesn't change the fact that the son existed and was a living human being. A gay marriage might not yet be legally recognized in most of the United States, but you can bet a married gay couple from Massachusetts still considers themselves married when they visit Georgia. Abandonware exists, period. This is simply a semantic argument.
Also, let's put it this way: Some copyright holders allow their titles to become freeware or public domain, most often with no further support. I would consider this "freeware" to be a form of legal abandonware. You might insist on calling it freeware, but I think the key issue is availability and support. In addition, sometimes copyright ownership is ambiguous or unknown even to the companies that hold the rights themselves. It's pointless to argue about the ethics and morality of it, because we all have different standards - it's all about how you get through the night.
One can pay high prices to third-party sellers for old games which are far in excess of what contemporary games cost - money which, in all likelihood, will never go to the original creators of the game. One can download a game which is unlikely to be released in the near future, and thereby technically infringe on the rights of some holding company that doesn't care one way or another whether some IP they bought as part of a package deal 10 years and 5 CEOs ago is being "pirated" or not. It's all part of that grey area inherent to life.
I like GOG. I have no problem paying a nominal amount for old games. I think every form of media which can be transmitted digitally should be available for immediate download, for a reasonable fee, and with no strings attached. Eventually, that will probably be the case. In the meantime, I don't lose too much sleep over things like abandonware. If I really thought Wiz VII had been released to the public domain, I would have given a link - I just don't want people arguing further based on an offhand comment I made.
And please take no offense from my arguments about the existence of abandonware, either, Gundato. That's just how I view things. You're saying that it doesn't legally exist, and I'm saying that it doesn't have to be legally recognized to exist. We obviously both pay for games, let's call the whole thing off.

I can call shoplifting a "five finger discount". I can rob someone who walks down a street and call it a "7th avenue toll". I can mug someone at the ATM and call it an "ATM withdrawal tax". I can hold up a kwik-e-mart and tell them they are paying a monthly "property tax" and the like.
So sure, by those definitions, "abandonware", the "five finger discount", and the like exist. They exist in the sense that they are all words that people redefine every five seconds so that they can justify breaking the law.
Again, someone can buy an import copy of a game and pay "high prices" to Amazon or whatever for shipping it. Money that will never see the developer or publisher. Or one can just pirate it and be done with it.
One can pay 50 dollars for a new game, and realize most of that money is going to the publisher, not the devs. Or one can just pirate it, and call it even.
There are many ways to justify piracy. Do whatever you want, call it a "grey area" if it makes you feel better. But, as far as the law is concerned, it is VERY easy to mark the black side and the white side.
avatar
Gundato: I am just going to speed things up:
Abandonware is a form of piracy. Simple enough.
Any form of "abandonware" is piracy. Any form of "warez" is piracy. I don't care how you justify that it deserves to be called "abandonware" instead of "warez". It is still piracy. And, by the letter of the law, it is piracy.

I never said taking advantage of abandonware wasn't copyright infringement (at least in some cases, if not most), in fact I've said the opposite several times. I just said abandonware has a specific meaning to most folks and it usually means you can only get it second hand or maybe not at all, at any rate not from the copyright holder or their agent.
Calling it piracy by "the letter of the law" is somewhat spurious as copyright infringement is not called piracy in any cannon of law of which I'm aware. It's a colloquial term, with a meaning that most folks understand, just like abandonware.
avatar
reddog000: My favorite series of all-time. Actually played the original on an Apple IIE back in 1982 or 1983 I believe. I have the archives on CD and Wiz 8.
I might have to dig out these just 'cause I saw this thread. Blasphemy to you all ;) Hoping they will run on Win7 64-bit.
PS - I still have the original Clue Book for Crusaders of the Dark Savant. I have used it so much over the years it kinda looks like an old pirate map!

Since all the Wizardry games from before Wiz 8 are DOS games, none of them run natively in Windows 7, but run perfectly through DosBox. Wizardry 8 runs fine on Windows Vista and 7, but you have to run it in administrator mode, otherwise the saves get corrupted. Aside from having to run it as administrator, there are no problems running them in Windows Vista or 7. neither 32- or 64-bit.
Since all the Wizardry games from before Wiz 8 are DOS games, none of them run natively in Windows 7, but run perfectly through DosBox. Wizardry 8 runs fine on Windows Vista and 7, but you have to run it in administrator mode, otherwise the saves get corrupted. Aside from having to run it as administrator, there are no problems running them in Windows Vista or 7. neither 32- or 64-bit.

Well not quite all of them, as there is also Wizardry Gold which is a Windows version of VII.
Man I need to get out my Ultimate Wizardry Archives disc and really get serious about playing the series, I've tried to start it a couple of times but never followed through because I'm too easily distracted by other games.
Post edited September 14, 2010 by somberfox
avatar
fisk0: Have any of you played the 2000 "Wizards & Warriors" game, if I remember correctly it was made by some of the people behind Wizardry 5 or 6. I have it and the graphics are still really beautiful in my opinion, but the game is extremely buggy, to the point I have a hard time actually playing the game since the interface doesn't work properly, of course, it has a lot of the forest walking parts many of you seem to have disliked in Wizardry 7 too.
I saw an early build of Wizards & Warriors at E3 in Atlanta a long long time ago. D.W. Bradley showed me the game demo and I was hooked. It looked great then but the final game had its flaws, still great fun and finished the thing. Still have my Bane of the Cosmic forge save game disk. Wizardry 8 is a great game and I would recommend 6,7, and 8 as well as Wizards & Warriors for the hardcore.

We would pull off 24 hour Wizardry session in University, when one of us had to sleep or go to class another one of my roomates would take over great stuff.

I wrote an old school iPhone RPG (Archers and Alchemist) but it still doesn't capture the feel of some of these Good Old Games, back to the drawing board I guess.