It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
Maggie Thatcher was my favorite movie critic!
Not wait, something's wrong here. Wasn't that thread about Roger Ebert and his opinion about video games?
I am not against your Thatcher discussion, but please have it in another thread.
avatar
Elmofongo: I did not even care what he said about games not being art because:

A. HE IS A FILM CRITIC, OF COURSE HE WILL SAY THAT TO GAMES BECAUSE HE IS A FILM CRITIC!!!

B. There are game developers themselves who thinks games are not art and Hideo Kojima is one of them.
avatar
SirPrimalform: There's also C. He was very old. To him it probably only felt like a couple of years since Space Invaders came out. Most people of his generation have a difficult idea of thinking about computer games as being anything but bleepy alien shooting.
And D. He saw The Wizard in 1989 :P
Post edited April 10, 2013 by Elmofongo
IMO Ebert was outdated, I'm not sure why anyone cared what he said after about 1995. I found myself being more annoyed by his comments as time went on, mostly because he'd say stupid stuff that was either incorrect or irrelevant.

I don't blame him for it, everyone has their day and slowly loses it.

He also seemed to take issue with newer technology.
Post edited April 10, 2013 by Shinook
I can credit Ebert with atleast one thing, he did inspire The Cinema Snob.
avatar
Cormoran: I can credit Ebert with atleast one thing, he did inspire The Cinema Snob.
And because he mentioned it I stumbled upon the Nostalgia Critic, and by extension the Cinema Snob and Spoony and Linkara and so on.
avatar
Fesin: Do you have any idea what I actually wrote?
I know what you wrote yes.
avatar
Fesin: she was probably as destructive to the world as Stalin
Convenient of you to ignore that when you replied to me. And that statement is frankly laughable.

As for Thatcher having a huge impact on the world, as I said, the world is not the UK, or even Europe.
There are lots of foreign leaders who admired her and what she did, but mostly in countries where what happened in the UK (i.e. getting rid of much of the nonprofitable industry and refocusing the economy on services, slashing social benefits) had already happened before.
In France, for instance, she had zero effect on politics except as yet another right-wing figure to hate. Well, there was a very short amount of time when a right-wing PM tried Tachterite policies, but there was such a public outcry it lasted less than a year, and any reform was promptly undone by the next left-wing government.

The point is that outside of the UK, what's happened economically since the 80s in the world would have happened even if there had been no Thatcher. There were plenty of other people who had the same ideas, Reagan included, and furthermore, globalisation and desindustrialization in the West are economic trends that didn't need politicians to happen.


But as I said, this thread is supposed to be about Roger Ebert. I couldn't help myself from replaying to you, but I won't derail the thread any longer.
People are stupid. Especially the living ones.

/thread
avatar
Gabelvampir: What is going on with him? Is he such a drama queen or did he do something really terrible?
I normally do not read this (or any forum) enough to catch random forum drama.
Nah, he just said something pretty shitty in the first thread about Ebert that went up, and is now convinced a secret cabal of Roger Ebert fans are downvoting him for it. Personally, I would bet anything that people are only downvoting him for complaining about it so much, turning it into a vicious feedback loop. But he doesn't seem to agree.
avatar
keeveek: /thread
Whoops, didn't see this. Wish I had.
Post edited April 10, 2013 by PenutBrittle
avatar
Gabelvampir: What is going on with him? Is he such a drama queen or did he do something really terrible?
I normally do not read this (or any forum) enough to catch random forum drama.
avatar
PenutBrittle: Nah, he just said something pretty shitty in the first thread about Ebert that went up, and is now convinced a secret cabal of Roger Ebert fans are downvoting him for it.
Oh shit, he is on to us. We should lay low for a while.