dachshundfan: ive been wanting to introduce my sister to some of the old games that i play, but i feel that a lot of the ones i like are either too complex or too mature for her. i would love for my sister to experience and enjoy strategy games and rpgs and i was wondering if there are some heavily simplified variants of these games that would be easier for a beginner player to learn and later graduate to more complex ones.
11 year old girl and no one has mentioned the Creatures series yet? :) They''re adorable, and cover the basics of a lot of strategy while having a very low amount of violence.
The Creatures games are a cross between raise-a-pet and RTS, with bonus AI theory thrown in. The strategy part is mostly base-defense, gear management and exploration. For example, finding a mud-gun and hooking it up to a door to drive off raiding critters from your base. Or grabbing a mud-gun and using it yourself.
Skill trees come in the form of teaching your critters words and training them to use machines. The raise-a-pet part is fun and focuses on interacting with the critters as small children - the player teaches them words and how to do things, takes care of health problems, etc.
Critters can teach each other once you get a critical mass of adult critters. I'd recommend Creatures Village, it's the kids version that's less complex and a lot of fun. That might be aimed too young for an 11-year-old, so maybe Creatures Exodus would be right, depends on how she handles complex interfaces.
I really liked Lord of the Realms 2 (started playing when I was 11-ish) - it's TBS, with a nice interface and the voice acting is reasonably good. Covers a bunch of strategy without overwhelming players. And the AI was predictable enough that battles weren't usually a challenge, plus I could auto-resolve if I was willing to sacrifice troops.
For puzzles, Logical Journey of the Zoombinis and Lost Mind of Dr Brain were great, but those aren't on GOG and I don't know about their compatibility with modern systems. There's a more modern Zoombinis game that was pretty good - Mountain Rescue or something like that? World of Goo is probably the best recent puzzle game, followed by Cogs.
FWIW, she may not enjoy RTS and strategy games. I didn't usually at 11, and they're not my favorite genre still. Are you looking for those because you think she'll enjoy them, or because you think they're a blast and assumed she would too? EDIT: More game recs!