zavlin: you'll always find people in this discussion that want to claim somthing is only underrated based on numerical review scores measured in a finite way. Try to remember that whether somthing is underrated is a complete opinion used to describe the sentiment that somthing didnt receive the amount of praise it "should" have.
That's true, but if you just base it on sentiments, we could have the whole forum cluttered with threads about "underrated" games, even though they're on top of the wishlist already and everyone here knows about them.
Also note that you're defending opinions here, and I didn't offer anything else. I didn't claim certain games are NOT underrated, I just said that *I* personally wouldn't call them that, and that's an opinion to describe a subjective sentiment, too. And by that definiton *I* still think Planescape Torment is an underrated game, btw. ;)