dudalb: Correct. Fact is Both companies do a lousy job on their drivers.
ATI used to have a slight edge in backwards compatibility, but apparently the newest generation of cards does away with that.
I noticed that ATI abandoned XP just before Win7 was released. Support actually decreased dramatically.
Although when I ditched the card I never realised what extremes they'd take that to. When I gave my ATI card to my brother he could barely start Windows XP for the error messages. It wasn't until he got year old drivers installed that it worked fine.
So they aren't just killing off backwards compatibility. Anyway, I've actually had much better backwards compatibility since I switched.
It's just a shame that both companies can't focus on fixing existing problems rather than constantly trying to outdo each other. Especially when the hardware their previous generation's hardware still isn't being taxed at all by any current game. It's also pretty clear that Nvidia can't yet push performance any harder without setting the whole computer on fire in the process.