Continuing my journey of exploration, I've now voted for... let's see...
Blocks That Matter,
Closure,
Conquest of Elysium 3,
Crayon Physics Deluxe,
The Dream Machine (a point & click adventure game made entirely of clay and cardboard?! I'm in!),
Kentucky Route Zero (You can never have too many point & click adventures. Or at least I can't.),
The Misadventures of P.B. Winterbottom,
Papo & Yo (I would have voted for this one just to support racial diversity in games, but as it is, it looks darn cool),
Proteus (how does this have so few votes?!),
Q.U.B.E.,
Rochard,
and
Samorost 1 & 2.
(The rest of the Ss and the Ts will have to wait for tomorrow.)
Also, I've take the liberty of adding some links and descriptions to the wishlist pages which don't have much information. I hope this doesn't come off as presumptuous - I'm just trying to help other clueless newbies get a sense of what each game is about.