hedwards: And other times like with the original Quake, you have to wonder what the designers were smoking.
michaelleung: I can't believe you didn't like Trent Reznor.
I like Trent Reznor fine, but the sound track for Quake wasn't particularly well thought out. Not that it's entirely his fault, the game in general couldn't decide where it was set. You've got medieval themes, technology themes, it's a design disaster from start to finish in terms of design.
But, it's saving grace is that it's a FPS and quite frankly, plot is beside the point, it's no wonder that it took so very long before there were any decent games of that genre that included any plot at all. Painkiller was one of the notables to just admit that it's not a genre people tend to turn to for a good plot.
michaelleung: I can't believe you didn't like Trent Reznor.
saramakos: Any of Trent Reznor's works went well with Quake 1... I loved the soundtrack for it, but I loved playing it more with "The Downward Spiral" in the drive... you would start the game and the demo would start with "Big Man with a Gun" blasting out... worked perfectly!
And that's the problem right there. Quake wasn't designed to be anything in particular, they more or less nailed the gameplay, but the design elements were mailed in. The issue I have with his work on the game is that the soundtrack sounded as if it was written for something else and failed really to express the particular Quakeness of Quake.
I ended up playing without it most of the time just because it didn't really add anything. FPS is a tough genre to right music for. You've got no particularly good way of knowing where a person is going to be when they're listening, unlike other genres where there's identifiable plot points to work off of.
Porkdish: Within a few hours I'd heard so many repeats of certain radio songs that I just went batshit insane. In game that is. I can't walk into a room in that game and not immediately seek out any and all radios and switch them off.
Delixe: Heh, that would be Big Iron. There is a bug in the playlist that ensures it plays more than any other song. Download the NV version of GNR More where that came from or the NV Radio Extender to add songs of your own to Mr New Vegas' playlist.
Is that what was going on there? I thought it was just because the selection was really limited that the songs seemed to play all the time. In retrospect, a DLC pack of more songs would be very much appreciated.
What I like about the songs on that soundtrack is they all fit the theme of the game, and they're all good songs. The problem I have is that even good songs tend to wear at you after 30 or 40 hours of repetition and a game like this is going to be played for a lot longer. And having to choose between radio on and missing what's being said is kind of annoying.
But, then again, I chose to get the PS3 version, so no mod fixes for me.