Since the unholy blizzard are being dicks about warcraft(yes I know, its a guilty pleasure) I've decided to dive into my older games collection. This is what I surfaced with.

Carmageddon 1 or 2
Starlancer
System Shock 1 or 2
Majesty(no expansion)
Civ 2(original or multiplayer versions)
Jedi Knight 2(with expansion)
X-Wing vs Tie or X-Wing Alliance
Homeworld 1 or 2
I-war
Total Annihilation:Kingdoms(no expansion)
Lander(Pygnosis)
Hexen, Heretic or Heretic 2
Jagged Alliance 2
Grandprix Legends
Fallout(If anyone knows where my fallout 2 disk is, email me)
Die by the sword(no expansion *sob*)
Rainbow 6(up to 3, all expansions)
Warhammer 40k: Chaos Gate
Mechwarrior 2 or Mercs

So, someone tell me what to play.

Fallout...

Damn, I would love to see a Carmageddon remake. :D

Total Annihilation: Kingdoms - because it's not on GOG, while it obviously should (and very well could) be.

System Shock 2!

Civ 2, definitely Civ 2.

SECONDED!

I'd say System Shock 2, then Carmageddon 2. You've got a great collection of games to choose from, I must say so myself.

Homeworld 1

X-Wing. No space game beats the X-Wing/Tie Fighter series.

I've gone with a combo of Homeworld 2, system shock 2, Kingdoms, Krondor and Ignition. Muha!