stonebro: Along with Enslaved I'd say this game is the biggest surprise positive of this year. Enslaved perhaps even moreso since it wasn't very advertised here, I just saw it at the store all of the sudden and bought it in a drunken stupor.
I've played both (but not finished any) now and Castlevania is the better game by far. Much more depth to the gameplay, in fact I'd say it rivals God of War 3 in that department.
Beating God of War 3 on Titan difficulty (which is brutal) is a good warm-up towards beating Castlevania on it's equivalent, but it's not fake difficulty. If you're good enough you can breeze through without ever dying, just takes a lot of practice to become that good.
I just finished it at 3am this morning (it was so strong at the end I just kept saying, "one more puzzle", "one more boss", ...).
Awesome ending and like I keep saying, super deep combat system. Yeah, Paladin mode on combat heavy levels is brutal (3x Greater Werewolves == ouch!). I've literally caught myself saying, "Man, I'm doing really well here," then I take a hit, lose my focus (game and real life) and I'm dead not 10 seconds later.
I don't want to spoil anything, so I won't post a video, but I've watched ones where people literally slugged it out with some of the toughest bosses in the game and got perfect block after perfect block, and knock down after knock down on them.
These bosses are hard. If you reduce the difficulty the game doesn't give you more health, more healing items, or less enemy HP. Everything still works the same except the enemy attacks slower. How about that? The game is so well balanced and the combat system is so deep that that's the biggest difference I noticed between the difficulty levels (and may be the only one, in fact)! You still have to handle a warg like you should or you're going to die. There's no difficulty that will let you sit there and tank damage or out-dps your foe.
Also, everyone ranks the final boss way high on difficulty, I actually had very little problem with that boss, even on Knight mode (we'll see how Paladin goes). It took me a few extra tries and I pressed one of the cut-scene action buttons too soon and got insta-killed, but other than that I really felt like there was way more room for error than on some other bosses.
I plan on taking on the chapter 3 boss on Paladin tomorrow, if I can do that, I can do anything in the game, imo. I'll probably play through Enslaved afterward, before finishing up Castlevania on Paladin.
Again, it still gets my game of the year. I might recommend the PS3 version so you can avoid the disc switching which gets awful old. That's my biggest gripe, even though I installed both discs on the hard drive, I still was stuck swapping discs. When you do play this (as you all should), tell me how you feel when you pull off a perfect, upgraded ground cutter on a big baddy:)