I played about one third through the DC now and I agree with all the comments here: The game has a LOT of little inconsistencies and niggles that make it a much less well-rounded package than the original. That's not to say that the additions are terrible, some of them are really nice, but it just does not fit well together.
The worst offender are the new Character Portraits by Dave Gibbons. While they are beautiful on their own, they do not fit at all to the style of the whole rest of the game. They stick out like a sore thumb,
The Interface is also all over the place, the inventory actually obscures some item closeups, the really cool original way phone conversations were handled (George writes all numbers on a used envelope along with pointless doodlings) is completely gone, the stupid flashing hotspots have been mentioned already, in short: it's just a fucking mess compared to the simple but elegant interface of the original.
Lots of little dialogues and cutscenes have been deleted (I noticed the scene where George hides in the wardrobe in the Hotel Ubu, and since all Death scenes have been removed, the scene when he tries to leave the hotel with the manuscript is missing as well)
Please, GOG team (and Revolution Software), let us choose between the Director's cut and the Original!
Edit: Oops, wrong thread, but it fits here as well...
Post edited December 09, 2010 by Lafazar