Thanks for the replies.
Gambit: That summary looks very useful indeed, it could be a very big help. I think we're going to try playing it today. I'll post some impressions when I've had a go at it.
Crassmaster: If you wouldn't mind, Zeewolf, please post some thoughts when you finally do get a chance to play. Some friends and I have been considering checking out Arkham Horror, so I'd be interested to see the thoughts of someone new to the game.
Right, was obviously going to post this a lot earlier, but GOG kind of prevented me.
But anyway, I've played it once, and that took a good few hours. It seems like it'll be quite fun, but the first time we played we spent most of the time reading and following the instructions in the manual, and it wasn't really until the later part of the first session that we could basically do a complete turn (with some fighting and stuff) without having to double check the manual to see if we were forgetting something.
So the first hours with the game were kind of heavy (maybe draining is a better word), more work than fun to be honest, but I'm seeing a lot of potential here and now that I have a slightly better grasp of the whole thing, I'll definitely it again soon.
Edit: Hm, seems I couldn't make a new post. :-/ I hope you get notified of my reply...