Crassmaster: Pretty good article on Quarter to Three looking at what went wrong with 38 Studios. Among other bits : They weren't making ay revenue on Amalur. Their publishing agreement with EA gave them $35 mil up front, but EA kept 100% of sales revenue. That's just unbelievably stupid.
http://www.quartertothree.com/fp/2012/06/04/what-happened-to-38-studios/
SimonG: Or smart. How often did that game sell?
And isn't it usual that devs get paid a fix amount and the pubs get a rich via the sales. Same with New Vegas.
Edit: Those 35 Mil are pure profit from their point of view. I would guess EA made less money with the game.
I think EA probably made back its nut, or close to. They got over a million sales plus any DLC. They'll also reap 100% of whatever long tail sales occur (which could strategically be big, especially if they heavily discount it on Origin right before a major holiday to try and drive people to install and be checking Origin during the holidays).
As for 38 Studios, you're right, no matter how good of a deal they'd gotten on profit, on that number of sales with a publisher involved it's unlikely they'd have cashed in to the tune of 35 million, plus they wouldn't have even managed to launch the game.
Also, nearly six years on a MMO without a screenshot or write up on mechanics? What the fuck did they do all day?