That's not a wishlist . This is a wishlist. :p

Seeing as I seem to have misread, these are the games on my wishlist currently:

Perimeter
Prince of Persia: Warrior Within
Prince of Persia: Two Thrones (I bought Sands of Time but am waiting to try it out before I get the others)
Avernum: The Complete Saga
Avadon: The Black Fortress
Avadon 2: The Corruption (same situation as PoP: got Geneforge 1-5, waiting to try that first)
Divinity: Original Sin & DLC (wanting to get this for me and a friend to coop as I think she should like it)
Age of Wonder 3 Deluxe (got the prior AoW and Divinity games on a Humble Bundle. Waiting to play through before I consider actually buying them)
The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky (JRPG fan)
STALKER: Clear Sky
STALKER: Call of Pripyat (same situation as PoP)
Valdis Story: Abyssal City (Metroidvania, stuck on to remind me to check out thoughts and reviews)
Xenonauts
Reprisal Universe (Populous spiritual successor. Mix of wanting to play Populous and see reactions)
Magicmaker
Dreamfall Chapters (waiting for me to play TLJ and Dreamfall)
Gods Will Be Watching (stuck on to remind me to check out thoughts and reviews)
Baldur's Gate Enhanced Edition
Baldur's Gate 2 Enhanced Edition
Icewind Dale Enhanced Edition (all these three EEs are for curiousity. I've got the originals)
Pillars of Eternity (stuck on to remind me to check out thoughts and reviews)
This War of Mine (oh man so tempted to get from Humble store right now)
Wasteland 2 (stuck on to remind me to check out thoughts and reviews)

I hate saying "I called it!", but I so called it!

*sigh* We are all doomed...

From what I've played, it's open-ended sandbox. Just keep tending to and raising your Norns and see what unexpected genes may pop up. There may be more definitve goals in the later ones, but I've only played the first -- I have tendancies towards needing to play a game series in order as much as I can.

(Though I'm pretty bad at keeping my Norns alive at the moment. I really need to put the manual on my tablet or something so I have it easily accessible -- I might have a degree in a field related to biology, but I still need help recalling what some things are telling me.)

*Grabs tinfoil hat and runs for the bunker

I believe in CDP Red, but as for now there's only one trailer for Cyberpunk, I can't muster much anticipation ;)
On the other hand I got to play Witcher 2 only a couple of months ago (after a hardware upgrade) so I still have the "tell me what happens next, and tell me NOW" buzz.

That''s the short wishlist, the actual one is considerably longer. +1 for Dundee reference though ;)

From the games I don't own I'd probably pick:
Legend of Grimrock 2
Shovel Knight
This War of Mine

What I recommend getting if YOU don't have it yet:
(Desperados)
FTL
Gothic
(Gothic 2)
(Guild Gold Edition)
HoMM 2 and 3
King of Dragon Pass
Master of Magic
Race The Sun
System Shock 2
Wasteland 2
and the LucasArts games

Sorry for including removed games. :P

Here is some of my all-time favorites which are on GOG :

- Rollercoaster Tycoon (the first) : Gestion but not only : the core of the game is the rollercoaster building and the park conception : you build what you want, the way you want. The gestion part is here only to make you think about how to do what you want with this scenario (which are well thought). If you love rollercoasters and amusment parks, you should take a look.

- Oddworld: Abe's Oddysee (and Exoddus) : two of the best think-platform ever. The world, visuals, gameplay, puzzles (and you must save your friends without using any weapon)... One of the best. But not easy one.

- Carmageddon : Because of the music, athmosphere, gameplay, and humor.

- Duke Nukem 3D : one of the best FPS !

- Heroes of Might and Magic 2 : I discovered it here, and I'm trying to finish the base campaign. I love visuals, music, and gameplay : a turn-based strategy mixed with two strategy levels and RPG elements.

- Clive Barker's Undying : good story and athmosphere.

And some which I never played but will buy someday but still need to advice ( know they will be good : I heard so much good about) :
- Arx Fatalis
- Ultima VII
- Wing Commander IV
- Descent 1 & 2

Edit : Or did I misread and you wanted a wishlist ? I understood you wanted suggestions for you... If I've mistaken, sorry for this ^^" All I wrote was advices !

Interesting. Okay, thank you for helping me get more info about it. =) Also, I'm pretty sure you didn't misread anything. The question was one thing and now it seems to be mutating into everyone talking about wishlists. -laughs-

Additional - just started playing Baldur's Gate EE. Got it since I could not, no matter how hard I tried, get multiplayer to work. It comes with its own glitches to work out, but the multiplayer runs, at least. Also, it should be interesting to see what the experience is like with all the extra class kits that are available.
(And yes, I'm sure that if I dug through the mods and got them all working, I could have something just as good if not better. But with my luck, they'd probably break everything so I went the simpler route.)

Listen to Mr Cheese Biscuit - grab a tinfoil hat and run for the bunker, if you're lucky there will be more than just chocolate flavoured food supplements.

Like cheese topped flour-based food products

[I can't stop obsessively editing this post. Time for a little break while I calm the hell down.]

Not at all, man, you're good. =)