Leroux: Well, it depends on the definition of classic, but we're also missing
Pool of Radiance: Ruins of Myth Drannor (2001). It's not
that old and from what I hear not a very good game, but there are enough people who voted for it to come here.
Almost any game tied to a particular IP/franchise would have people vote for it, just because some people love "completion"/"collection". If someone published an RPG called
Dogshit which was savaged in reviews for its awful gameplay, and because every time you had a party wipe in the game, it caused your computer to shit itself and die, then almost no one would vote for it. (
Almost no one.) BUT, if that same game was a licensed product called
The Elder Scrolls: Dogshit, or
Dungeons & Dragons - Forgotten Realms: Dogshit, or whatever, there would probably be hundreds of votes (maybe thousands) from fools wanting to throw money at garbage just because of the licensed property it was associated with.