If you do play it, I'll be looking forward to your review. :D

A Wolf Among Us
Kings Bounty Legend
BIT.TRIP.BEAT

I noticed that they add games to the Mystery Star stash apparently.
Should I just wait til the last day to try out a star or two?

The best games usually have very limited quantities. You are better off trying earlier than later.

Good lord no. My condolences.

I took a shot at this, bought 10 stars in a couple batches:

Set 1:
- Sacred Gold
- Barony: Cursed Edition
- Noctropolis
- King's Bounty: Dark Side
- Sherlock Holmes: Nemesis - Remastered

Set 2:
- War for the Overworld
- Z: The Game
- Batman - The Telltale Series
- BIT.TRIP VOID
- Tales from the Borderlands

I own a couple of them elsewhere...but overall, I think I made out with a pretty good haul! I'm pretty sure I already had some of them on my wishlist, but you can't tell after you own them.

Combat Mission: Beyond Overlord
BIT.TRIP FLUX
Crime Cities
Unrest
Antihero
RollerCoaster Tycoon 2: Triple Thrill Pack
Timelapse
Terra Nova: Strike Force Centauri
The Moment of Silence
Toren
Sam & Max: The Devil’s Playhouse
Sam & Max Beyond Time and Space
Game of Thrones: A Telltale Games Series
Star Wolves

I'm arriving quite late but I wouldn't mind giving Hard West a try if that's still ok with you.

can't help myself, 2 more:

Scanner Sombre
Codename Panzers: Phase One

Holy Potatoes! We're in Space?!
UFO: Aftershock
Toren
Ys: The Oath in Felghana
Samorost 3

aaaand

Game of Thrones: A Telltale Games Series

New one:

Hector: Badge of Carnage

New ones
Order of the Thorne: the King's Challenge - this sounds very nice
S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Call of Pripyat

I opened a support ticket since I thought it was an error that I got Aliens versus Predator Classic 2000 and Requiem: Avenging Angel. The text says you'll get a game worth between that amount and in the Winter Sale but neither of those two are on sale. Is that not an error? If not that seems a bit sleazy, those games typically go on sale for less than 3USD.

Also, in the star pool there's Kim.