Posted January 13, 2017
k4ZE106
New User
Registered: Nov 2014
From United States
DosFreak
is awesome
Registered: Sep 2008
From United States
Posted January 14, 2017
If I would have gotten into army, I probably would have broken down in the first week, maybe the second, but no longer. I don't think it's a healthy place for highly sensitive people with autism or other psychiatric vulnerabilities. But I didn't know my vulnerability yet when I was about to be conscripted.
That's why the comment about the Korean army (which Korea?) surprised me: what if the disabilities are mental, do you need to serve anyway? I don't think a soldier would be much good if he gets into mental breakdown, depression, catatonia, psychosis or whatever way a vulnerable psyche would react to being bullied by a sergeant, let alone the sound of guns firing on the practice range and the possibility of the stresses of actual combat to top it off.
I'd end up crying, shaking, angry, upset or very scared very soon by bullying sergeants, not having a place for your self to come to rest, over-exertion and the loud bangs of guns firing on a practice range.
tiny E
Find me in STEAM OT
Registered: Dec 2012
From Other
Posted January 14, 2017
If I would have gotten into army, I probably would have broken down in the first week, maybe the second, but no longer. I don't think it's a healthy place for highly sensitive people with autism or other psychiatric vulnerabilities. But I didn't know my vulnerability yet when I was about to be conscripted.
That's why the comment about the Korean army (which Korea?) surprised me: what if the disabilities are mental, do you need to serve anyway? I don't think a soldier would be much good if he gets into mental breakdown, depression, catatonia, psychosis or whatever way a vulnerable psyche would react to being bullied by a sergeant, let alone the sound of guns firing on the practice range and the possibility of the stresses of actual combat to top it off.
I'd end up crying, shaking, angry, upset or very scared very soon by bullying sergeants, not having a place for your self to come to rest, over-exertion and the loud bangs of guns firing on a practice range.
timppu
Favorite race: Formula__One
Registered: Jun 2011
From Finland
Posted January 14, 2017
And even if you don't have any (diagnosed) disabilities, you could alsays choose one year of civil service instead, e.g. working in some retirement home or whatever. It is easier too because you get to go home every night, unlike in army.
I had a friend who couldn't stand staying in the army so he faked having a mental breakdown, opening the window and starting to scream in the middle of night. His superior came to tell he should visit the army doctor, which then diagnosed him as being not fit for military service, so he got an exemption.
Oddly though, later he regretted having not finished the service and wanted to get back...
For physical disabilities, a friend of mine who wanted to go to service was about to get an exemption against his own will because according to medical records he had had some kidney operation as an infant (it didn't affect his health at all as an adult). He protested and eventually got to the service.
I guess nowadays quite many young men here choose civil service instead, going to army isn't considered that important anymore by most, and it hardly ever helps you finding a job, ie. the employers aren't really interested whether you've been in the army or not. If you want to become a truck driver or something, it might be beneficial if you get to become a truck driver in the army first etc., not sure if it was even possible to acquire the (pretty expensive) truck driver license in the army.
For my own "service", there were both positive and negative things, but more of the negative ones. For instance, having to live together with people you couldn't necessarily get along that well (I guess the meaning is to learn to work with also "incompatible" people, but still...). I even got into a fight once during a march with someone I didn't get along that well. Then again, there were nice people there too, but I guess all the stress etc. could also get under people's skin and sometimes get the worst out of them.
Post edited January 14, 2017 by timppu
P-E-S
I like games
Registered: Nov 2008
From United States
Breja
You're in my spot
Registered: Apr 2012
From Poland
Posted January 14, 2017
ussnorway
New User
Registered: Jun 2011
From Australia
Posted January 14, 2017
In Australia we have anzac day and yes people have thanked me on that day but in the past 5 years or so the service has become a F joke put on for tv so I don't go any more
p.s, @mistermumbles, I have never see an old soilder call themselves a hero
p.s, @mistermumbles, I have never see an old soilder call themselves a hero
Post edited January 14, 2017 by ussnorway