After everything was said and done I had purchased around 40 games .. not a single crit. However I need to point that purchases were made from one of several PCs, a tablet, or my phone in my house. I don't know if it mattered that they were not all purchased while I was on the same machine.

bought 10 games and scored two criticals:

- Indiana Jones (kept)
- Freedom Plant (gifted)

well, I am lucky, I guess, and very grateful :-D

edit: corrected the number of purchased games from 9 to 10.

Check your mailbox.

I have not tried to click on many of the offers, but very, very casually, still had good luck, getting a Bird Story and Consortium, though owning them on Steam, thank you GOG, a welcome addition and free gifts!!

I got the crit that makes everyone jealous:

Ink (movie)

Beat that! :p

I did, they did. Awesome, thanks!

Wasteland 1
Broken Age

Ended up with a total of 5

Teslagrad
Wacky Wheels
Vangers
Alan Wake's American Nightmare
The Raven: Legacy of a Master Thief

Just wanted to add I also got Torchlight I already had (so now I feel like a true veteran with a Torchlight Gift :)
And
STAR WARS®: TIE FIGHTER I had to add to my account as I couldn't click on the gift box on My Mobile, But I contacted Support.

So in Total from the start of the Promo
Bought Deponia (well it wasn't free but I did buy it for practically nothing at the start of this promo)
Got Kentucky Route Zero Season Pass (Gifted)
Got Capsized (As a gift)
Got Dracula Trilogy (already bought it on last promo so also As a gift)
Got Torchlight (Had it from some previous promo so also As a gift)
Got STAR WARS®: TIE FIGHTER (Added to My Account, Contacted support to turn it into a gift)

The only game I know for sure I saw a and clicked 3 times is INDIANA JONES® AND THE FATE OF ATLANTIS™,
but I couldn't make up my mind if I want to spend 3$ on it as I felt it must get lower eventually and I already have too many in my back log to spare me from revisiting games I already played... Would spend a 1.5$ in a heart beat though :)
Other then that, I guess I clicked a couple of hundred (some recurring) titles, though clicks on mobile might not be registered properly - on some occasions I had to click numerous times - did anybody had a critical after clicking more then once, letting it load a bit, then click again and wait until fully loaded?

So First 3(?) Days were on Firefox with 3 games and through Mobile after Mar 4, 2015 with 2 more games seems to be not bad at all :)

Here's a list of what everyones said so far. I've use IamSinistars format for this post and included the number of copies available from each round. From BlackThornys post, I only included TIE fighter and torchlight because I'm not sure which others are actually criticals. Keep in mind this list may have errors as some posters have make new posts regarding their critical hits instead of updating their old ones. I have tried to make sure I didn't double count anyones critical hits but some may have slipped though. I know people have posted criticals in the promo tracker thread but I haven't included them here for obvious reasons. Hoping some more people will come here to post there criticals. :)

Seasoned

4x 7th Guest (-75%) [150] [150] [100]
1x 11th Hour, The (-75%) [150] [100] [100]
0x Age of Wonders 2 The Wizard's Throne (-67%) [100] [200] [100]
3x Another World: 20th Anniversary Edition (-60%) [250] [100] [100]
0x Arcanum: Of Steamworks and Magic Obscura (-75%) [350] [400] [600]
0x Assassin's Creed: Director's Cut (-75%) [150] [100] [200]
2x Bad Mojo Redux (-80%) [250] [150] [250]
1x Bard's Tale, The (-80%) [150] [200] [250]
0x Battle Isle Platinum (-75%) [150] [150] [200]
0x Beyond Good & Evil (-75%) [200] [400] [400]
0x Black Mirror 2 (-75%) [150] [150] [100]*
2x Children of the Nile Complete (-80%) [150] [150] [150]
2x Clive Barker's Undying (-75%) [150] [200] [250]
0x Corsairs Gold (-75%) [150] [100] [150]
0x Dark Reign + Expansion (-75%) [150] [100] [150]
2x Darkstone (-75%) [100] [150] [150]
0x Deus Ex GOTY Edition (-75%) [350] [200] [200]
3x Dracula Trilogy (-80%) [150] [100] [200]
3x Entomorph: Plague of the Darkfall (-75%) [100] [100] [100]
0x Far Cry 2 Fortune's Edition (-75%) [150] [150] [200]
1x Gex (-67%) [150] [200] [250]
1x Gobliiins Pack (-75%) [150] [150] [150]
1x Great Battles Collector's Edition (-75%) [100] [200] [300]
3x Haegemonia Gold Edition (-80%) [150] [-150] [150]
4x Heretic Kingdoms: The Inquisition (-75%) [150] [250] [300]
2x Hitman 2: Silent Assassin (-80%) [150] [100] [50]
0x Hitman Contracts (-80%) [150] [300] [450]
3x Hogs of War (-75%) [150] [100] [50]
3x I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream (-80%) [150] [250] [250]
2x Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis (-50%) [400] [800] [1200]
1x Jade Empire: Special Edition (-80%) [300] [400] [500]
1x King of Dragon Pass (-75%) [250] [300] [200]
2x Knights and Merchants - The Peasants Rebellion (-50%) [150] [100] [200]
3x Labyrinth of Time, The (-75%) [100] [150] [200]
3x Legend of Kyrandia, The (Book One) (-75%) [150] [250] [200]
3x Little Big Adventure (-75%) [150] [100] [150]
0x Little Big Adventure 2 (-75%) [150] [100] [150]
4x Medal of Honor: Allied Assault War Chest (-75%) [150] [200] [250]
3x Monster Bash (-75%) [100] [150] [200]
0x Myst Masterpiece Edition (-65%) [150] [150] [150]
3x Nexus - The Jupiter Incident (-80%) [200] [400] [400]
6x Nox (-75%) [150] [250] [250]
0x Pharaoh+Cleopatra (-75%) [400] [400] [400]
1x Realms of the Haunting (-75%) [150] [150] [300]
0x Red Faction (-80%) [150] [100] [100]*
3x Red Faction 2 (-80%) [150] [100] [50]*
0x Return to Krondor (-75%) [100] [150] [100]
2x Return to Mysterious Island (-80%) [150] [150] [150]
0x Riven: The Sequel to Myst (-75%) [200] [200] [300]
3x Robin Hood: The Legend of Sherwood (-80%) [150] [150] [200]
2x Sam and Max Hit the Road (-50%) [400] [800] [1200]
1x Septerra Core (-75%) [100] [150] [150]
1x Seven Cities of Gold: Commemorative Edition (-75%) [100] [150] [150]
3x Shadow Man (-75%) [100] [100] [100]
2x SpellForce Platinum (-80%) [200] [150] [150]*
0x Spycraft The Great Game (-75%) [100] [150] [200]
4x STAR WARS: TIE Fighter Special Edition (-50%) [200] [400] [600]
4x STAR WARS: X-Wing Special Edition (-50%) [200] [400] [600]
0x Stronghold HD (-75%) [150] [150] [200]
0x Sudeki (-75%) [200] [200] [300]
0x The Black Mirror (-75%) [150] [150] [150]*
3x The Last Express (-75%) [200] [200] [300]
1x The Secret of Monkey Island: Special Edition (-50%) [300] [350] [350]
1x Theme Park (-75%) [250] [250] [150]
2x Thunderscape (-75%) [100] [100] [150]
0x Tomb Raider 1-3 (-70%) [150] [200] [200]
3x Two Worlds (-80%) [150] [200] [200]
1x Unreal Gold (-80%) [200] [300] [200]
2x Uplink (-75%) [100] [200] [200]
0x Uru: Complete Chronicles (-80%) [150] [100] [100]
0x Vampire: The Masquerade - Redemption (-75%) [300] [200] [400]
5x Vangers (-75%) [100] [100] [200]
3x Wacky Wheels (-75%) [150] [100] [250]
0x Witcher: Enhanced Edition, The (-85%) [350] [350] [400]
1x Wizardry 6+7 (-75%) [100] [150] [200]
2x Wizardry 8 (-80%) [200] [200] [200]
6x Wasteland (-75%) [100] [150] [150]
5x Worms 2 (-75%) [150] [200] [150]

Fresh

5x A Bird Story (-60%) [150] [250] [600]
2x A Story About My Uncle (-80%) [100] [200] [100]
3x Aarklash Legacy (-80%) [200] [150] [100]
0x Age of Wonders 3 Deluxe Edition (-67%) [150] [150] [300]
3x AI War Collection (-80%) [150] [300] [100]
2x Alan Wake (-85%) [100] [150] [200]
3x Alan Wake's American Nightmare (-85%) [100] [200] [300]
1x Among the Sleep (-67%) [100] [200] [300]
0x Angry Video Game Nerd The Movie {movie} (-50%) [150] [100]
0x Anomaly 2 (-75%) [150] [100]
0x Anomaly Defenders (-75%) [100] [100] [100]
6x Astebreed (-75%) [100] [300] [200]
2x Banished (-70%) [300] [600] [900]
0x Banner Saga, The (-60%) [150] [300]
2x Battle Worlds: Kronos (-80%) [150] [300] [450]
4x Blocks That Matter (-70%) [100] [100] [100]
5x Braveland Wizard (-50%) [150] ???[150]
4x Broken Age Season Pass (-67%) [200] [300] [300]
6x Capsized (-80%) [100] [150] [150]
1x Cognition: Game of the Year Edition (-80%) [150] [300] [200]
2x Consortium Master Edition (-80%) [200] [250] [200]
1x Dead State (-67%) [150] [200] [400]
4x Defender's Quest (-85%) [100] [200] [300]
3x Desktop Dungeon (-67%) [200] [400] [300]
2x Din's Curse (-75%) [200] [400] [600]
6x Door Kickers (-60%) [150] [200] [350]
3x Dreamfall Chapters Season Pass - Special Edition (-60%) [150] [350] [600]
1x Driftmoon (-85%) [200] [100] [250]
3x Drox Operative (-75%) [150] [150] [300]
4x Freedom Planet (-67%) [150] [300] [200]
0x FTL: Advanced Edition (-75%) [300] [600] [200]
0x Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers - 20th Anniversary Edition (-60%) [200] [400] [600]
4x Halfway (-70%) [150] [400] [400]
0x Hammerwatch (-75%) [150] [200] [400]
2x Ink {movie} (-50%) [100] [100] [50]
2x Inquisitor (-85%) [150] [250] [400]
2x Kentucky Route Zero Season Pass (-60%) [150] [300] [200]
3x Last Federation, The (-75%) [200] [400] [150]
2x Legend of Grimrock (-80%) [250] [500] [800]
0x Legend of Grimrock II (-50%) [200] [400] [600]
1x Lumino City (-50%) [100] [100] [200]
0x Mark of the Ninja Special Edition (-80%) [200] [500] [400]
1x Metrocide (-60%) [100] [100] [300]
2x MIND: Path to Thalamus (-75%) [150] [200] [400]
0x Mousecraft (-70%) [100] [150] [150]
2x Neverending Nightmare (-50%) [100]
1x Papers, Please (-75%) [350] ??[300]
3x Pier Solar (-67%) [200] [200] [600]
2x Pixeljunk Monsters HD (-85%) [100] [100]
1x PixelJunk Shooter (-85%) [100] [100] [100]
3x Quest for Infamy (-80%) [200] [200] [200]
1x QUBE Director's Cut (-80%) [100] [200] [200]
2x Raven, The: Legacy of a Master Thief (-85%) [100] [100] [300]
0x Rayman Origins (-75%) [200] [400]
1x Risen (-80%) [200] [400] [600]
1x Sacred 2 Gold (-80%) [150] [300] [500]
1x Shadowgate: Special Edition (-80%) [150] [500] [800]
2x Shadowrun: Dragonfall - Director's Cut (-60%) [300] [600] [900]
2x Shadowrun Returns (-80%) [350] [450] [900]
1x Shadows: Heretic Kingdoms (-60%) [150] [350] [400]
2x Signal Ops (-85%) [100] [200]
1x Sir, You Are Being Hunted (-80%) [150] [150] [200]
3x Smugglers V (-80%) [100] [200] [100]
1x Spacecom (-75%) [100] [200] [300]
2x Strike Suit Zero Director's Cut (-80%) [150] [200] [300]
3x Terraria (-80%) [300] [600] [300]
4x Tesla Effect: A Tex Murphy Adventure (-80%) [350] [400] [200]
4x Teslagrad (-75%) [200] [100] [100]
2x Tetrobot and Co. (-75%) [100] [200] [200]
0x The Frame {movie} (-50%) [100] [50]
1x The Gamers: Dorkness Rising {movie} (-75%) [150] [150] [100]
3x The Vanishing of Ethan Carter (-60%) [200] [400] [600]
0x The Witcher 2 (-85%) [350] [300] [600]
3x Torchlight (-85%) [150] [200] [200]
5x Two Worlds 2 Epic Edition (-85%) [200] [200] [400]
0x Wasteland 2 Digital Classic Edition (-60%) [200] [400] [600]
3x Xenonauts (-60%) [200] [400] [300]

I only got a crit on Gobliiins in what I believe was the first round. Nothing after that.

Thanks for the rundown, but where did you see Wasteland 2? No one in this thread reported that one.

I messed up when checking the context of Breja's post, my bad, I'll fix that.

I'll also add the results from the other 2 posts while I'm at it

Okay, understandable, a lot of people quickly changed away from format into writing out what they missed, what the wanted etc. rather than simply writing what the got. Confused me too.