You mean you put all the contents of the bundle to upgrade to the definitive edition in your cart and checked out and it didn't charge you anything, and now all the DLC in that bundle show as being owned by you?

Nope, I obviously got regular edition, but I'm able to upgrade.

So it's totally not non-upgradable.

Well, that's great. Humble Bundle is selling what they claim is the definitive edition, but actually is not the definitive edition. This is blatant false advertising.

It's typical HB.
It's worthy of complaint, though. Do you have any organization where you can file a complain? Report it?
We in EU do have those, so maybe I file a complaint at some juristiction.

I have no idea, but here, the agencies that are in charge of regulating companies are run by the companies themselves, because that's such a smart idea.

I see this now:

Where do you see that? Basically what they're saying is that the definitive edition is not the definitive edition. In order to upgrade the definitive edition to the definitive edition, you will have to purchase the DLC that are required to upgrade to the definitive edition. All of this DLC requires you to already own the definitive edition to be able to upgrade to the definitive edition, which may or may not be an issue, seeing as how you both do and do not have the definitive edition.

It's in the game description when you select it, apparently. Those of you with a subscription would need to confirm this as I cannot.

Maybe they really changed the way they present it to say that the definitive edition is not the complete edition and the definitive upgrade is just an upgrade available for the definitive edition

I don't see anything like that, but I haven't tried to buy it, and if it's only the base game, I won't bother.

That's as safe a play as any other.

I assume, at least based on what I've read across a few posts made everywhere else, that you don't have to select each game right away and can read the descriptions, see videos and any other things relevant to whether you'd want to potentially use up a choice on them.

I see that now that I've tried to buy the game. They claim it's worth $59.99, when in reality, it's not for sale, and it's not the definitive edition, which is required to upgrade to the definitive edition, so it's worth $0. Apparently it's only the base game, not the definitive edition, and it's also somehow the definitive edition, but not the definitive edition. This is blatant false advertising, and intentionally confusing. I'm not buying this trash on general principle.

It's part of what started to piss me off with Humble in general. While I don't necessarily feel like they always need to roll out the full package with games like this, it's absolutely clear that the version of the game being pushed on most storefronts is now the definitive edition (which includes that other content) and it would've been better for Humble to have worked out a deal accordingly that delivered that version to their paying customers.

Man, the Dec Monthly unlocks are underwhelming.

So from the final Monthly I'm keeping Yakuza and Chasm, while from the first Choice I'm keeping SotTR (non)Definitive, Blasphemous and Desert Child. Everything else is trade fodder atm, though if I don't arrange for good deals I might keep Horizon Chase Turbo and Aegis Defenders.

Though I'm interested in Horizon Chase, I don't think I'll be getting this humble choice.