I do hope that this wasn't serious. If this was serious, I think and hope that you were wrong, and would ask you to please continue playing with us in future!

Please list the oddities you saw?

Welcome!
In the Harry potter game, where the OP stated that slytherin=mafia, Yogsloth came in and his first post was "Hi, I'm goyle from slytherin, now I'm going to read the rules." He got away with it because it was during RVS (the joke-for-want-of-anything-else-to-do stage) and because it fit his personality. Yogs turned up scum.

As to the voter's intention in this case, I do not know. I could see it as any of a) annoyed, b) serious or c) meme-ing.

[Refreshed the page and saw #69 & 73, which are way better than my explanation.]

I have voted. For ZFR. Check post 51 again.

The reason i am suspicious of the 3rd seat is that meta play says the middle seats are going to be filled with mafia.
Reasoning: Mafia want to miss-lunch any non-mafia. They will stick out if they are the hammer, or even the L-1 vote. They waste(?) their vote starting a wagon that no-one else agrees with. Thus, they tend to hop on the middle of a wagon to avoid scrutiny and to go with the flow/have a valid defense. Since their goal is to live while eliminating others, they don't want to have too much scrutiny placed on themselves, and middle of a wagon means they weren't the only ones who saw something fishy. Ofc, mafia know this reasoning and will also avoid sitting in the middle seats to avoid scrutiny. xD

What scene's reasoning is, i cannot say, and am interested in it.

HAHAHAHahaha. lololol. This really made me chuckle; thank you!
(No offense meant, GR!)

Also on what basis?

It's a fluff for GR vote, why? I was role-playing according to OP post, he was not happy to see me. So it's *serious* in a way. Or what did you mean exactly, especially a part about "playing with you in future"?

Cadaver Slim always keeps his word. In due time means not now.

I think it's more likely to be a bot.


I mean, were you talking about the ones you already revealed? Is everyone who doesn't see the same oddities as you suspicious, or is there a specific reason why you think she should have seen them? Are you waiting to see if she has similar thoughts to you that you're keeping to yourself for the time being or do you mean that more will come in time as people make more posts? Or something else?

@Lift, woops sorry. Didn't notice you already explained the background.

In agent's defense, when he wrote it Joe's rules weren't posted yet. I made the OP for Joe since he couldn't start new threads, and I just wrote basic ones without flavour.

Also, what broke the game wasn't this mistake but the second blunder he made: when he claimed that roles got reshuffled later, and that initially he was scum with trent.

I agree though that these kind of jokes stop being funny after a while. They're nice for a chuckle the first time they were made, but then they got carried way too far.

No, there are more like I mentioned already. Everyone who act oddly is suspicious for me. The meaning of "oddity" is subjective, human error is one of the many possibilities. Pooka is experienced and intelligent player so his statement about not seeing other possibilities is very odd for me, maybe not for you or anyone else. I'm not waiting for anything, I just collect my personal list of oddities and mistakes, make the links, do research. I don't want to put all my thoughts right away before others post more, because otherwise they may hide their true intentions.
Do you think I should provide my analysis right now? If yes, why?

You seem to... try too much. Like calling lonzi's question LAMIST. Feels like fake-scumhunting done for the sake of showing that one is scum-hunting.

That's it? I haven't called it LAMIST I said exactly "a bit too LAMIST for my taste", the possibility of being LAMIST was not ruled out completely. I never false scum hunting, I'm a real deal, Cadaver Slim's reputation is at stake!

...

OK.

You're not fake-scumhunting, but a bit too fake-scumhunting for my taste.

Again, not true. Check my posts and tell me that it was the ONLY scum hunting on my behalf.

Ah, I misunderstood and was afraid that you'd been offended IRL by something and weren't going to continue playing this game. I was asking that, even if you felt you had to drop out of this game due to some offense, that you would still play in future games of mafia.

I'm glad to hear that I was wrong in my understanding.

Oh yeah, I'd forgotten that bit! He claimed he had been scum with Trent but no longer was and Trent flat out denied it. We ended up getting them both on the first two days.

I've no reads so far, but random bragging rights trio: Micro, Cadaver and ZFR

Joe is prodding me, despite the fact that I never signed up. This is a violation of my human rights!

Vote Large the Lift

He has the name of a strongman

@lonzi, I take it you played Mafia before?

What's wrong with Micro, me and ZFR?

Well the smell aside, your facial features suggest that you are members of the criminal underclass.