temps: Many of you on this forum talk about how important it is for you to get your video game software DRM-free. But what about your OS software? To my understanding, Windows has DRM. After all, there are user-friendly and easy to use DRM-free operating systems like Pop OS and Linux Mint you could use instead.
To me the real issue with DRM is whether it's under your control or someone else's. Eg, serial keys and CSS on DVD's are DRM but are also a non-issue as the offline DVD game / movie can't be remotely revoked if the store you bought it from closes and you can "back up" serial keys into notepad and saving that a few times. You can't be remotely prevented from playing / watching, soundtracks won't ever be deleted due to rights expiry, etc. If Windows can be made to behave the same offline, it's less of an issue vs online game activation, and to give MS rare credit, non-activated restrictions for Windows have actually eased up over time.
What happens if you never activate Windows:- XP - Will work for 30 days then refuses to boot. The whole OS permanently stops working until you type in an activation key.
Vista - Will work for 30 days then enters Reduced Functionality Mode (you are blocked from playing built-in games, Aero & Bitlocker are disabled, and you are forcibly logged out after every hour). Also blocks System Updates.
W7 - An "Activate Windows" watermark appears on the desktop. Will work for 30 days after which you will get hourly "Activate Now" nag screens (that revert Personalizations) along with a notice that your Windows version is not genuine whenever you launch the Control Panel. Also blocks System Updates.
W8 - An "Activate Windows" watermark appears on the desktop, and you'll lose access to Personalizations. "Activate Now" screen popup nags every 6 hours.
W10 - An "Activate Windows" watermark appears on the desktop, and you'll lose access to Personalizations but otherwise continues to work with mostly full function.
Likewise, local KMS activations (over a LAN by a company server) can be done "offline" for Pro, Education & Enterprise, and W10 Enterprise LTSC in particular is literally built for specialist use cases (including air-gapped / specialist factory floor / MRI scanner, etc, stuff with no direct net connection and unchanging stable environments). It's possible for them to activate offline and work continuously +10 years without ever seeing the Internet even once. So the "DRM" there is like the offline DRM on DVD's, serial keys, etc (a lot less of a problem than online DRM in games). In theory, Enterprise versions are not available to consumers. In practise, well there are 'ways around that' and a lot of gamers seem to like LTSC anyway due to less bloat.
As for Linux, I do dual-boot with Linux Mint 20.2 (XFCE). Some stuff is still fiddly / flaky but it's come a long way from where it was and if it ever came to completely ditching Windows altogether, most of my favourites & classics run fine on it, many natively. Likewise, emulators, ScummVM and DOSBox stuff tends to work exactly the same for DOS / Win31 games under
Linux as it does
Windows and people build all sorts of matchbox sized retro rigs out of Raspberry Pi's.