toxicTom: I think game sequels fall into different categories:
- Cash-grabs, milking the franchise - yes happens
- Yearly cash-grabs ;-) (Hello EA Sports!)
- Technical improvements (visuals, physics...), while staying true to the original
- Let's expand/change compared the original (Civ...) - always a matter of taste
- Let's make a new game that continues the story (Witcher)
- The first made us some money, now let's make the game we actually had in mind (many indies)
Especially with games sequels are often better than their predecessor. Not always, of course. If I made a list of games where I found the sequel better than the original, it would be pretty long.
Civilization II was better than the original. Apparently another sequel,
Call To Power is the best of all these (I haven't played it yet).
AB2012: …
Bad sequels : … Torment: Tides of Numenera, …
Is it "not worth playing" bad or just "not a patch on the original" bad?
hummer010: NOLF 2
Age of Empires 2
Civ 2 / 3
I think Civ 2 was better than 3. The worst part of the game is the mess that rail makes across the maps; ignoring this, though I think the gameplay is superior.
I could very well be suffering from rose-tint, though, as I haven't played it for decades. (I did play it to death when I first bought it, though. :)
DavidOrion93: Civilization 2 was better than the 1st one. Civ4 I consider the best sequel, imo.
Europa Universalis 3 was better than its predecessors.
My rig is not powerful enough to play
Civ 4 for very long, but I kinda prefer
3 to it. (Though the stacks of doom suck, and the scenarios of
4 are a great addition.)
ignisferroque: DX2 wasn't technically a bad game when seen on its own I think, but as a sequel it missed almost everything that made people love the first one. It's definitely the worst in the series for me.
GameRager: DX2 has an awesome intro/pretty good starting levels/story … the pilot/transport choice leading to different hub/level start points, and the inclusion of the omar …
I think the
Invisible War demo that was released contemporarily is much more fun than the actual game. (Obviously the narrative is puddle-deep.)