dtgreene, yeah, I would probably agree about how a really great game can't be too old. I was talking more about the graphics. Unfortunately, these do get old.
Interesting how all the things you didn't like about FF 7 and 8, I loved. The cutscenes, in my opinion, are actually a real boost to these games and gives them soul. But with some games, you just don't get into them for some reasons, that's probably what happened to you with FF 7 and 8, because these games, in my opinion, are extraordinary. But sometimes it just doesn't work. For example, I loved Persona 4, and having never played the previous one, I bought it, but forgot about it after a couple of hours. I just didn't get into it.
The FF 7 and 8 spaceship thing was an incredible experience, I spent hours roaming the world in solitude and having my mind blown away at unexpected things happening and discovering all the secret locations. I'll never forget in FF 8 I would roam around the huge plains, and sometimes catching a glimpse of a UFO whizzing by, and never understanding how the heck I would find out about it, until I finally did much later. Or just flying over a section of the ocean where I would have bet I would not have found anything, and instead an incredible battle took place. A new ability called 'throw' was gained, so I started throwing at this huge Godzilla thing, all the stuff I didn't need, but the more valuable the item, the more damage it caused. I ran out of items to throw (could not use magic anymore as I had run out of ether potions, which were very rare and expensive to find and buy), so in the end in an act of desperation I started throwing all my money at the enemy. I literally threw at it even my underwear. After 20 minutes of gruelling battle, I was half dead but alive, and I had won.
It's just these things and exciting surprises that I see a lot of modern games, lack. For example, I bought The Witcher 1 years ago, and after 3 hours of going around finding the next herb for the next diseased stranged, I just gave up. I tried so many and especially the PC ones never seem to really cut it for me. For example I played Fallout 3, Morrowind, Oblivion, even Baldur's Gate 1 and 2 and Torment Planescape, but never really was blown away. The only one that stood out to me was Neverwinter Nights. Now, I would never say that Baldur's Gate is a weak game, in a hundred years. But for some reason with some games you just don't get immersed enough in them. I don't know.....I am pretty fussy. Ironically, it was FF VII who kind of set a standard that I have never really been able to
As for the spaceships in FF and motion sickness, at the time I did not have the motion sickness problem. The latter only happens with certain games when there's too much going up and down too fast. For example, I'd rather avoid a first person game like the Elder's Scrolls or something like that.
I do agree about the absurdly long spells in FF VII, though....they were just ridiculous! :) That's the problem with JRPGS, they have some real nonsense! And the story is ALWAYS nonsense. But the gameplay and the battles....wow.
Not saying that I am right, just that for some reason often it just doesn't work. For example, it was very difficult for me playing and enjoying 100 hours of FF 8 , madman style, and then go back to the graphics of FF5 or 6. But, I have no doubt the FF you mentioned is a great game. Just that the graphics are a step back from the later FFs.
And yeah, the later ones, I did not like. I completed FF X but I did not enjoy it as much as the other ones. I could not roam the world on the flying ship, they took one of the best things of the game. As for the later ones still, I literally remember buying FF XII, playing it for 45 minutes, putting it back in the case, and forget about it. One stupid thing Square Enix does, is changing the battle system to a completely different ones, in every later game. Who wants to sit in there and studying a completely new turn based system? I just want to see new moves, items, spells, summons, etc....not a contrived new system that requires an hour of study. FFXII had all these crazy lines thing there, and worst of all, had a 'politics' story. Who the heck cares about politics? We want to be swept away in a awesome world of magic and emotions, not controlling a character who's trying to run for office :)