It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
avatar
JMich: Relevant.
Unfortunately, hijacking the "constructive or not" rating system is much easier to accomplish.
avatar
Maighstir: The distorted word ones are by now so quick for a computer to solve that they're pretty much useless, they're catching up on the "identify the picture" ones too.
avatar
timppu: I quickly read the CAPTCHA Wikipedia article which mentions these machine-learning robots defeating CAPTCHAs, but in case you know more:

Is it like the robots recognize e.g. cars in any pictures (or like one MS-proposed CAPTCHA. telling cats and dogs apart), or is it merely that those robots routinely store all the images they encounter into a database, along with the right (or wrong) answers? Or do they do both?

If it is the latter, then I guess they should come up with CAPTCHA systems which don't use pre-generated pictures or stuff, but generate the pictures on the fly? Possibly there are such already?

EDIT: But then if there is a robot who can generate new pictures and decide on the fly what is the correct answer... then I guess it isn't necessarily hard for another robot to learn the correct answer as well using similar algorithms... damn this is confusing.
I only have very rough knowledge, but it's based on machine learning. Figuring out -based on earlier knowledge- what the current image most looks like (a C, an A, and a T; a feline pet; or a bulldozer), not trying to store half an infinity of images, going through them each time and being confused when a few pixels change because the checksum isn't known.

And yes, computers are becoming better than us at the stuff we specifically use to make systems computer-proof.

We teach computers to read and understand distorted and hand-written text, and then try to use distorted text to keep computers away from only-humans-allowed systems.

We teach computers to recognise myriads of traffic signs in various angles and light configurations, and then try to use pictures of use traffic signs to lock computers away from system we only want humans to have access to.

Confusing? Yes.

Google does both cases in the latter at the same time. You get multiple images, some of which they know are <thing>, and some of which the computers are not yet entirely sure is <thing>, so they ask you to confirm in a way that you don't know which is "I think this is a <thing>, but I'm not entirely sure, can you tell me?" and which is "I know what this is, do you?".
Post edited November 29, 2017 by Maighstir
Quit being a poorly programmed robot then.
CAPTCHA? What's that? Can you eat it?

I also have my browser set to delete everything when I close it, but I only get those 4 numbers in my mail for authentification code to log-in, just like Steam, but that's probably because of my IP changing every time I turn off the system.
Post edited November 29, 2017 by Elisebathe
avatar
Maighstir: not trying to store half an infinity of images, going through them each time and being confused when a few pixels change because the checksum isn't known.
Ah yes, that would be quite simple way to make the "store all images with known answers" tricky, as CAPTCHA could randomly change a few pixels here and there which would not affect us human, but would make them appear as new pictures to a database robot.

Oh well, if there is a silver lining to this arms race, cyber security professionals probably have work to do for the rest of their lives. If one day someone would inform "there, now everything is completely secure", then all those (CAPTCHA) professionals would be laid off!
Post edited November 29, 2017 by timppu
The basic problems of captchas is, that they should be solvable also by stupid humans, but not by smart algorithms. As computer algorithms get more sophisticated it gets ever more difficult to find something that all humans can solve, but computers cannot. As a bonus, captchas are also specifically used to train machine learning algorithms. So it won't be long now that every captcha that can be solved by the majority of humans, also can be solved by computers.
Store fronts, cars, streets, street signs. Three of those in a row, most of the time now. It's a bit much, GOG.
Just to mention, I still haven't seen the captcha recently but I am having to log in twice. Just happened and it happened yesterday.

Maybe I should stop logging out when I leave.

One of the banks I get to deal with uses the same captcha which you can bypass after you;ve solved it a few times. Maybe that's why I;m not seeing it here.

avatar
Lifthrasil: So it won't be long now that every captcha that can be solved by the majority of humans, also can be solved by computers.
We're already there and have been for years. There are also services that will (I say this as a fact since I'm familiar with the companies involved. A slur is not intended.) have someone in India solve it for you and they charge a few bucks per thousand views.
Post edited November 29, 2017 by drmike
well i always feel like doing a world travel during solving this captchas ^^ and ya some sequences can be pretty annoying
The irony of all this is that a simple check to see if javascript is enabled detects most bots.

https://www.whatismybrowser.com/detect/is-javascript-enabled

:)
The op is right. It's f*cking annoying.
avatar
DreamedArtist: I am losing my shit with the captcha on the login page, 3 minutes clicking on car pictures, 3 MINUTES!! this is nuts. Is there a way to get rid of this thing with a script or program? waiting for pictures to change and doing this all the time is starting to make me go nuts.
avatar
Tauto: If that's a real life avatar photo then I understand why it takes soooooooooo long.
Love you too babe ;)
avatar
Elisebathe: CAPTCHA? What's that? Can you eat it?

I also have my browser set to delete everything when I close it, but I only get those 4 numbers in my mail for authentification code to log-in, just like Steam, but that's probably because of my IP changing every time I turn off the system.
You can get your ip to change like that? how does that work if you don't mind me asking? I wish GOG did a phone text with the digits to hit in instead of getting an email with the code, Seems more time wasting imo.
Post edited November 29, 2017 by DreamedArtist
I never ever see the captcha I just stay logged in.
I've been getting captchas non-stop for the last two weeks... don't know what it's all about, but I'd be grateful to the GOGBear if it stops. I am not a robot, I'm a meatbag! You should be able to tell the difference by now.
avatar
DreamedArtist: why does GOG even use this annoying thing anyway?
avatar
JMich: From what I recall, captchas trigger if there are multiple unsuccessful login attempts. Logging out and (successfully) logging in again shouldn't be triggering the captcha, so my guess is that someone has gotten hold of the username you are logging in with. I'd suggest turning on two factor authentication (if you haven't already) and maybe updating your password as well.
Captchas may trigger for other reasons as well, but unsuccessful login attempts should be the most common one. And they are there to prevent brute forcing of passwords.
I had that turned on from day one and it's annoying tbh, but I am sure if anyone was to log in I would have found out. I am sure even gog would know if I was to ask them if any other IP logged into my account. I do hope they keep something like that around but knowing all the sorry we don't keep personal info around It would be a sorry we don't know.

On a fresh install of windows 10 from 3 days ago with google chrome, Is it a chrome issue? cause I am aware many of you use Firefox. well I will have to set my browser to keep passwords then if this is something I can't fix.