Posted on: August 28, 2025

JJack
Verified ownerGames: 480 Reviews: 21
Great RPG, but weakest Witcher
I'll keep this short, because the "Most helpful review" by TigerLord already explains things in detail and I agree with most of it. For me as well, Witcher 2 is definitely the weakest part of the series. Yes, I actually liked the first game better. And, of course, W3 is beyond comparison as the best RPG *ever* (perhaps even best game overall - at least IMHO) and deserves 5+ grade. Now, don't get me wrong: W2 is *still* better than some 80% of RPGs out there. So, if it was a stand-alone game, not part of Witcher series, I'd gladly give him 5 stars. But as things stand, compared to the other two, I have to dock a star. Bottom line: W2 is definitely worth playing and I recommend playing the series in order 1-3. (I played them in order 1, 3, 2 instead and rather regret this decision.) Not just because the proper order makes the most sense story-wise (though if you've read the Witcher books, you know most of the background story already - and if you haven't, what on Earth are you waiting for?), but also because W1 gets you properly introduced to the series and gives you appetite for more. This will make the W2 play through more enjoyable, knowing that the absolute best is yet to come. :)
Is this helpful to you?