Enclave

It should not be this hard to figure out how to get from one room to the next. Like your game having horribly clunky controls shouldn't be part of the challenge.

The combat is awful! There's no feedback for anything and no way to stagger/stun the enemies. You and the enemies will be just trading blows, flailing around until one of you drops.

Graphics awesome. Campaigns for both light and dark side are great. Choice of weapons are spectacular. Buy the game.

Alright: it's been 12 years since it came out. I played it about 8 years ago. Don't go: it still looks fine. Together with the level design and music, it's purely CINEMATIC. Now, I don't have a lot of patience for older games, but when seeing the screenshots I can remember the sheer excitement. The levels were stunning, and you feel like you're living in this fantasy world. The leveling up stuff works great. The atmosphere is foreboding and immersive. The enemies are great, and the creatures you're slaying them with is even better. The game mechanics are worth just a 6,5 or 7, but in total, it's an adventure worth while. For this money, it's a complete no brainer. In fact, I'll have a look myself. Maybe I should play it again. Meet Mordessa and Vatar :D

Definetly an underated hidden gem. If you have ever played Hexen, you'll like this medieval fps game ! The gameplay is quick and addictive ! You can play in a subjective view or first person. I definetly recommand the last one. 2 sides are available (light or dark) with different scenarios (linear). The dark side being harder and for experienced player. The replay value is quite good as you'll unblock a lot of different characters (but limited to 4 main different types : warrior, bower, engineer, wizard). I see two main weaknesses : 1) the colision management present some weaknesses and it becomes boring at some points. 2) combos are very limited for such a game.