Posted on: August 17, 2024

A.G.B.
Games: 822 Reviews: 84
Fun for a little while
The coolest thing about this is probably the way that aspects change as the first person narrator changes details in the retelling. It does legitimately let you experience a lot of cool Western legends. Some of them are just pointless name drops but others do the thing that they’re infamous for and you are sometimes tasked with trying to stop them. The only positive thing I can say at all about the duel mechanic is that if you play the story mode it doesn't force it upon you all that often. I would definitely avoid the mode that is purely made up of those. Almost everything about the duels is frustrating. Probably my biggest issue with this is the fact that too often enemies blend into the background. This is obviously a problem for a game that is about you being able to spot them and open fire on them. I just feel like Where's Waldo shouldn't be an FPS. There's too little variety to the guns. I never found myself actually using a shotgun. I appreciate that they were trying to only go by what was available at the time and seemingly they also didn't want you to be able to pick up a tomahawk or a bow and arrow even as you see others use those. But they could still have done better. I haven't played the first three. It sounds like the first two are substantially better. I do not know why they dropped a bunch of features from those for this. It honestly seems like a very ill advised decision. The skill tree is nowhere near as satisfying and gameplay evolving as Dead Island by the same developer, a game that overall is inferior to this but definitely does provide much more engaging gameplay. I played all the way through the campaign of that three times not starting over mind you keeping intact all of the upgrades and such but still. This I doubt I'll play even a second time. The plot is paper thin. The ending feels too obvious and so much of this you spend bounty hunting but without the world building of Thief: The Dark Project which is also largely a series of jobs.
Is this helpful to you?