Same thing here. I waited about an hour after connecting the accounts and now it says that the accounts are successfully connected. However it said no eligible games were found. It correctly identified all of the games I already own on GOG (which is to be expected) but it looks like it wasn't able to see which of the remaining games I already own on Steam. I actually do have Braid and the Sherlock Game on Steam but not here yet, so I hit refresh and it says to wait up to a few days. I'm not in any hurry, so I'll check back later today and see if it went through :)

A couple of hours for me. I checked my library and those 8 games have been added. All good :)

Looks like I will need to wait for a day or so.

It did claim it could take "days" to happen, but obviously went through a lot faster. Hopefully, you'll wake up tomorrow and find it's gone through for you too!

I tried again just now and I got e-mail confirming the new games.

I went back and checked on my library. The new games are indeed there!

So bit more patience for everybody else is what the doctor ordered!

Did everything right, public profile and such, etc etc. Now it's telling me "no eligible games", but I have 3 that are. A bit strange..

Patience, it'll fix itself soon enough. ;P

That's got to be a VERY old Chinese saying...

It been 24 hours and I'm still stuck on:

YOUR ACCOUNTS ARE BEING CONNECTED
Due to exceedingly high demand, processing the queue may take up to several days. Don't worry, you will be able to add your games regardless of the wait. You can close this page now. Return later to manually add the games to your library.

:(

There's no need to panic, just read what it says.

Well, seems obvious, be patient.
It'll connect eventually.

48 hours and still waiting!

Is your account set to "public"? If it's set to "private" or even "friends only", it won't work.

God of Randomness says: Reconnect in ... hours!