It seems that you're using an outdated browser. Some things may not work as they should (or don't work at all).
We suggest you upgrade newer and better browser like: Chrome, Firefox, Internet Explorer or Opera

×
So, what else can we talk about while we wait? Or in other words to those who haven't voted yet: what are your thoughts? Are there still some questions to be answered before you decide?
avatar
supplementscene: @Zeo why was the last game titled Legend of the Cows?
What, are you talking about the fact that there were no cows? I mean, it was just a legend...
avatar
Lifthrasil: So, what else can we talk about while we wait? Or in other words to those who haven't voted yet: what are your thoughts? Are there still some questions to be answered before you decide?
What is your position on protein supplements?
avatar
Lifthrasil: So, what else can we talk about while we wait?
A very easy one.

zeo divides the remaining cards between 2 envelopes, such that each contains at least 3 cards.

He than randomly selects an envelope and then randomly selects 3 cards from that envelope.

How should zeo divide the cards to maximize the probability of at least 2L cards being drawn?
avatar
supplementscene: That's a good point. My thinking was the Liberal Chancellor would give Hitler extra town points as he knows the cards are as said. But like you say clearing a Fascist maybe even better strategically as the Fascist can cause turmoil down the line.

I hadn't actually wanted to talk about Fascist strategy as I didn't want to aid the fascist game. But if we don't look at their strategies they will be harder to find.
lower sunglasses and stares fixedly at Supple Scene for a solid two minutes, then shakes his head and puts the glasses back on

avatar
Lifthrasil: So, what else can we talk about while we wait? Or in other words to those who haven't voted yet: what are your thoughts? Are there still some questions to be answered before you decide?
I have now voted. Sorry for being MIA, the last couple of days have been busy.
avatar
ZFR: He than randomly selects an envelope and then randomly selects 3 cards from that envelope.
That certainly can change the chance of what is drawn, but not the odds of what kind of cards are drawn.

Why not shuffle the cards, draw 1,
shuffle, draw 1,
shuffle, draw 1?
avatar
ZFR: He than randomly selects an envelope and then randomly selects 3 cards from that envelope.
avatar
rtcvb32: That certainly can change the chance of what is drawn, but not the odds of what kind of cards are drawn.
Yes it does change the odds.

Consider this: He puts LLLF in one envelope and the rest (8F, 1L) in another.
The odds of drawing at least 2L becomes exactly 0.5. He needs to select the envelope with the 3 liberal policies (in which case he's guaranteed to get at least 2L). If he selects the other one, he definitely fails.

Now consider he puts LLLFFF in one and the rest (6F, 1L) in another. The odds of drawing at least 2L become smaller than 0.5. Not only he needs to draw the one envelope with 3Ls (0.5 chance), he then needs to make sure out of the 6 cards inside it he draws at least 2L.

So as you can see dividing those cards in different ways does change the odds of what kind of cards are drawn.

So, how should zeo divide the cards between the envolopes to get the highest probability of at least 2L being drawn?
avatar
ZFR: Yes it does change the odds.

Consider this: He puts LLLF in one envelope and the rest (8F, 1L) in another.
The odds of drawing at least 2L becomes exactly 0.5. He needs to select the envelope with the 3 liberal policies (in which case he's guaranteed to get at least 2L). If he selects the other one, he definitely fails.
...
But he wouldn't know which one had what. Yes they are bound to be unbalanced but unless you know which one is heavy in what, you're more likely to screw yourself and less to help yourself.
avatar
ZFR: ..............

@All, incidentally, how much experience you have with Secret Hitler.

.............
I own the board game and play regularly.
avatar
ZFR: @All, incidentally, how much experience you have with Secret Hitler.
I have never played Secret Hitler before this game.
avatar
ZFR: @All, incidentally, how much experience you have with Secret Hitler.
avatar
trentonlf: I have never played Secret Hitler before this game.
Ditto. I know pretty much only what i've seen from watching TB from 2-3 years ago.
avatar
supplementscene: .
Khm, I think you forgot to cast your vote dear Supple
avatar
ZFR: Yes it does change the odds.

Consider this: He puts LLLF in one envelope and the rest (8F, 1L) in another.
The odds of drawing at least 2L becomes exactly 0.5. He needs to select the envelope with the 3 liberal policies (in which case he's guaranteed to get at least 2L). If he selects the other one, he definitely fails.
...
avatar
rtcvb32: But he wouldn't know which one had what. Yes they are bound to be unbalanced but unless you know which one is heavy in what, you're more likely to screw yourself and less to help yourself.
You choose envelopes randomly. Don't look at their weight.

It's a mathematical problem. Divide them in such a way to give yourself the best odds when drawing. (By the way, those odd will be higher than the odds of randomly drawing from a single pile)
avatar
Lifthrasil: So, what else can we talk about while we wait? Or in other words to those who haven't voted yet: what are your thoughts? Are there still some questions to be answered before you decide?
I like to drag it out but I've voted now

avatar
Lifthrasil: So, what else can we talk about while we wait?
avatar
ZFR: A very easy one.

zeo divides the remaining cards between 2 envelopes, such that each contains at least 3 cards.

He than randomly selects an envelope and then randomly selects 3 cards from that envelope.

How should zeo divide the cards to maximize the probability of at least 2L cards being drawn?
2L and 1F in 1 pack and the rest of the cards in the other pack?
avatar
SirPrimalform: What is your position on protein supplements?
I'm fine with them as long as I'm not made into one.

avatar
Lifthrasil: So, what else can we talk about while we wait?
avatar
ZFR: zeo divides the remaining cards between 2 envelopes, ...
Why should he do that? That's not in the rules.