Ok, time to wrap this up. I hate judging creative entries, as it's so subjective. So I took all those that fit the 4 criteria and put them through to random. Sorry if you feel you'd have liked to compete, but it's the taking part that counts.

The runners up were:
bler144
MrKgnao
Chadjenofsky

The winner was:
Misteryo

I'll PM each to let them know. EDIT: At least I would, if GOG would let me. Seems we have new chat preferences. I'll add reply to each.

Thank you so much, wpegg. I wholeheartedly agree with your choice of winner. Good show, misteryo.
Congratulations to the other runner-ups as well.

My chat is set to "allow anyone". Did you have any trouble chatting me up?

Congratulations! Well deserved.

Can you send please me a chat message and post here when you did? I want to see whether I have a chat problem.

Sent you a message, somethings definitely screwed with GOG chat, have 2 outstanding ones I can't see.

OK, understood it now, it was my fault.

If you message someone offline, they appear way down the list, with no apparent indication it's them that is being messaged. They are still messaged though.

Thank you. Got your message and replied.

I have sent you a chat message.

Thank you. Got your message and replied.

Wheee! Thanks for the GA and for picking my entry!

Thanks very much wpegg! That was a great giveaway, and I enjoyed everyone's entry. May you have another 2000 days of Gog happiness!

Congrats to the winners and thanks again for the creative boost that gave us your giveaway! :)

Congratulations misteryo!!! That's awesome! Great entry!

Congratulations also to bler144, MrKgnao, and Chadjenofsky, very good entries as well!

Know what you're going to choose for your prizes? Please share when you do!

Great giveaway Jedi wpegg, the force was strong in this one!

I asked for Elminage Gothic.

I'm holding off to see what comes up for sale on Fri, but if nothing on my WL drops in price that's one of the handful I'm leaning towards as well. Others would be Unmechanical, Sokobond, Resonance, and Escape Goat 1 or 2.

I'm waiting to see what happens this weekend as well, but if nothing, I'm leaning towards:

Gabriel Knight remastered. I've started the original version 3 times and the darn pixels just get to me. I may be getting spoiled. But, I'd like to play this game, so remastered is attractive.

Lords of Xulima. Looks pretty good, but I do have an awful lot of epic rpgs in process all at once (Dragon Age: Origins, Wasteland 2, Pillars of Eternity - I'll really never get done)

Although maybe I'll take this as an opportunity to get something I would normally wait a long time for prices to go down. Like Outlast or Consortium or Sunless Sea.

I'll see what happens this weekend.