CSPVG: Having said all of this: Would any of you be willing to indulge me with a list?
Sure, what the heck. I'll bite. Skimming back over the thread, here's the most noteworthy things I've seen. The quality of these sorts of "tells" should be obvious. Order is roughly of order I came across it in the thread.
Wyrm: First to talk about doing anything with the corpse of cristigale. Lift, Sage, Bler, and CSPVG have participated.
CSPVG: Asking players for suspicion lists (Hijack, then JMich). Hijack declined to answer, JMich igored the question entirely.
Bler: First to bring up stats. Hijack, Lift, Wyrm, and Adalia speculated on stats too.
Sage: First to talk about powers of the ring (sort of). Wyrm and Bler speculated too.
Bler: First to talk about just ditching the ring/quest. Lift came out against it.
Dedo: First "accusation" of fishing.
CSPVG: Provided a list of 3 "suspicious" people.
Adalia: Asks someone (Wyrm) to appear scummy. Dedo counter accuses Adalia.
Lift: First "accusation" about breadcrumbing; his vote on Bler solidifies a little. Bler defends.
Trent: Questions about the suspicion list. JMich speculates on reason.
Wyrm: Suggests someone complaining about RVS lead the way out of RVS; declines to appear scummy to get out of RVS.
Wyrm: First to provide more serious game analysis/speculation. JMich discounts some of it.
CSPVG: Defends asking for suspicion lists. Opens the floor for alternatives.
-CSPVG actually seems to be doing a little work to get out of RVS. Wyrm too, or so I'd like to believe.
-Bler (presumably) joked about ditching the quest and getting out while the getting is good.
-Lift appears to be starting to latch on to what is likely a joke in order to push for a lynch.
-JMich seems a bit cranky about being stuck in RVS, but doesn't seem to be doing anything to try and move the game along. If one is feeling particularly uncharitable, his down playing of the (self labeled) useless post counting could be viewed as an attempt to break any possible momentum before it gets going.
-Dedo and Lift seem to be the first to question a player on "standard" game concepts (fishing, breadcrumbing) as opposed to non-relevant topics (a player's alignment in past games).
-Trent will probably object (with vote) to any attempts to talk about PMs or Roles.
So, in conclusion, I don't see anything that has happened that is vote worthy. The most objectionable things so far are probably from Bler (joke), JMich (RVS complaint with no alternative), and Lift (vote latch on joke). "Offenders" sorted alphabetically.
CSPVG: If not, how does everyone think we should proceed? Please don't simply tell me,"Do as we always do: We're going to hunt scum!"
How about we nominate Trent (or JMich) to come up with an idea to proceed! I've been itching to do this to Trent for a few games now, but either Yogsloth or I have shot our mouths off to try and break up RVS. No one has really talked roles or PMs (except for stats) yet, so this might be the perfect time!
Alternatively, select a player, call them a lurker, and vote for them. Most people are lacking in number of posts, content in posts, or both. Lynch the "lurkiest" player, and hope something interesting happens tomorrow.
-----
dedoporno: Sorry, it seems I screwed something up.
Here is the proper link. Fail number 2. As Quad says, it is still really tiny. I tried using Windows Magnifier, but the text is just a blur of pixels.
-----
HijacK: Huh. This reminds me I did a similar thing in the high school game, but in my case there was also collateral damage. >.>
I got a couple "WTF, Wyrm?" and then it was sort of forgotten about half way through Day 2. No collateral for me.
-----
Lifthrasil: One question about races: Bookwyrm noted, that the Mod post implies that our only hobbit was killed and muses about the other races. But isn't that something that should be very much apparent?
I'm looking forward to seeing whether we've got a bunch of orcs or goblins or something in our midst. Like "Oh, hey. I didn't notice he was a huge black orc with white face paint and "<3 EVIL" tattooed on his cheek until we killed him just now. Hunh, who let him in the party YOGSLOTH?"