bler144: My character is only middlin' smart
As evidenced by bringing a chess set on a dungeon crawl. ;)
dedoporno: I can't tell if I have a preference though, I'm not as set on Lift as bler is, but I can live with that in the current situation.
I think I'd prefer CSPVG over Lift, except he seems to be one of the investigative roles that we're apparently relying on. Neither one are in my top two, but I think either one beats No Lynch. Later: And now I see that CSPVG has claimed stats cop. Interesting.
bler144: 1) My counter would be, if you're hoping for something "stronger" on D4 to act on, what would that look like? Even if there is a town alignment cop, they would have to find a scum that shows as scum, claim, and be believed enough to get a wagon going. And then almost certainly be the NK on N4.
...
But step back and look at the bigger picture - if my analysis holds water then which of the two is more dangerous? Either Lift has an unknown power, and/or he's doing the NKs. If he is doing the NK it's possible he's untrackable. At this point a stats cop doesn't seem to help them as much as whatever lift would do.
-I'm not sure what we'll get on Day 4. I have this twitchy feeling/concern, so I'm voicing it. I find myself more or less buying into your argument (for better or for worse), if for no other reason than I think no one else will go for JMich or Leonard and I think No Lynch is a bad idea. If we lose a town Alignment Cop to the NK after he gives us his reads, then we come out ahead (unless that's game). We'll have 3 reads on players, regardless of faction, and we can go from there. Assuming said cop makes it to Day 4 in the first place.
-You make a convincing case. I was thinking of leaning towards CSPVG as the less useful potential role, but we don't know what Lift is yet either, and he's almost certain to be more dangerous than CSPVG. Look at the stats for Adalia and Dedo...
dedoporno: JMich and Wyrm, you are having a lovely discussion but your opinions on the things that are happening right now will be greatly appreciated.
Thanks, guys! U da greatest!
*Sigh* Fiiiine. If I haaaave to.
dedoporno: I don't have a vote on at the moment. I'm not pushing you to vote, either. I'm asking for you view on what has being revealed in the last few hours.
In order to get his preferred result, JMich doesn't have to do anything except wait and maybe slow us down a little.
-----
Working on a quick role recap. Will hopefully have it ready by the time the 10 minutes have passed.