Catte will recognise this one. I attempted the "do what I say today, and I'll go along with what you say tomorrow" approach in my last game, and which way did I flip?

Ignoring me and searching for scum elsewhere, maybe, and then coming back to me if need be later on.

Also read Post 433 for one possible proposal(it likely sucks compared to plans made by wiser minds, but it seems solid enough).

Aside: Do you honestly think a scum team would go with no NK if they're that size?

That's because one is more likely to be Town. In general.

Compare this against a baseline of 25%Mafia/75%Town instead.

And with that additional time I might be able to help get scum found and lynched....rare chance, yeah, but it could happen.

-------------

@ZFR: True, true....all i'm saying is that people were wrong then and they're wrong now. Anecdotal, I know...so take it fwiw.

err... No.

Absolutely not. Not when they have so many good options to hit.
And yet noNK is possibly better than removing what's for them a very convenient anti-Town distraction. What does that tell you.

*Sigh*

That this is all a load of barnacles.....everyone might as well say "You are the weakest link, good bye" and hand me my parting gifts at this point.

Ya know what...why prolong the inevitable?

Unvote
Vote GymHenson

Now someone just needs to do the honors and put me out of my "misery", so I can go sit in the obs thread and gawk in amazement at any future bad moves by my fellow town.

Any takers?

----

Also again, to town:

Try to remember my suspicion list....Catte, Vitek.

And to a lesser extent.....Dedo and Nmillar.

I'm not ignoring you, but this is just going to go around in circles unless you have some new reasoning.

From mafiascum.net wiki:
"Note that by claiming, you are opening yourself up to potentially being policy eliminated at some point during the game."

And that's in standard situation, not when the owner of the role is under heavy scrutiny and lied/ommited information before.


Take this as overall tip but this is simply wrong approach. Several players do the same thing but because you consider one of them scummy then his action is bad while it is not for others. In case you were town it would give you false reads. You should judge players based on their actions not judge those actions based on your reads.

If you were mafia and town did this, would you NK the person?
If you were cop, would you dare to investigate such person?

And you can likely then guess why I, in part, didn't want to fill claim.

All I will say is that I weigh players actions in some instances based on how I lean them.....that is just how I play.

Might do either in either case if I felt it was worth it....of course I don't follow the "by the book" play style many others seem to.

--------------

@Catte: Nope...sorry...nothing new to add.

Vote Count

Pookina (1) -------------------voted by nmillar (post 13)
GymHenson(4)---------------voted by Catte (Post 370), dedo (post 359), ZFR (post 412), GymHenson (post 441)
nmillar(1)-----------------------voted by JoeSapphire (Post 301)

It takes 5 to reach a lynch, GymHenson is closest at L-1

Day will end in 4 hours or so

While I wait for that hammer to drop from someone...anyone...some clips I found(as I browse YT at random) to pass the time.

1st one:

Robot Chicken-Rebels Win

Now hurry up and someone vote me already so I can go watch whopner.

Suuure.


Vote GymHenson

Thanks buddy

Now I can go relax while y'all "Super serious" players "show me how it's done".

-----------------

Well Op, that's yer cue to play me off.

Damn.
I hope you're fine.

You should stop kicking people and copiers.