Posted August 12, 2020

my name is catte
i touch your foods
Registered: Mar 2010
From United Kingdom

nmillar
↑ ↑ ↓ ↓ ← → ← → B A
Registered: Feb 2009
From United Kingdom
Posted August 12, 2020


Then again, maybe we should cut Gym some slack about recalling Day-chat too. It was mentioned this game and it was declared by the mod only last game, so I can see memory playing tricks on you.

JoeSapphire
Consultant Liar
Registered: Jun 2011
From United Kingdom
Posted August 12, 2020

Would Gym know about it if he didn't have it?
And if he did have it as scum, would he ask for a Cop investigation on the one Night he can be investigated?
And isn't the contention if he's scum that he's got day chat?
hm...
Novice Paranoid Gun Owner is a nice role though. Looks good on paper. It's not mentioned on the wiki,
but yeah it's not making sense is it?

nmillar
↑ ↑ ↓ ↓ ← → ← → B A
Registered: Feb 2009
From United Kingdom

ZFR
I love gold!
Registered: Jan 2010
From Ireland

my name is catte
i touch your foods
Registered: Mar 2010
From United Kingdom
Posted August 12, 2020
Let me get this straight.
You, knowing that on N1 your power wouldn't work, announced in your first post that you were a sPoRtsman. This was obviously picked up by everyone.
When you claimed PGO, this now made some sense because it seemed clear to me that you were trying to entice the mafia to NK you. That's the reason I believed your claim and unvoted, because your earlier behaviour made sense.
Adding novice onto that completely destroys that explanation. You didn't want to claim novice because you were scared of getting NK'd? But claiming a PR in your first post is a pretty good way to achieve that. Now we know everything you knew at that point (supposedly), the sPoRtsman claim doesn't make any sense any more.
You, knowing that on N1 your power wouldn't work, announced in your first post that you were a sPoRtsman. This was obviously picked up by everyone.
When you claimed PGO, this now made some sense because it seemed clear to me that you were trying to entice the mafia to NK you. That's the reason I believed your claim and unvoted, because your earlier behaviour made sense.
Adding novice onto that completely destroys that explanation. You didn't want to claim novice because you were scared of getting NK'd? But claiming a PR in your first post is a pretty good way to achieve that. Now we know everything you knew at that point (supposedly), the sPoRtsman claim doesn't make any sense any more.

GymHenson
Dearest of all my friends
Registered: Apr 2020
From United States
Posted August 12, 2020

That said, I tried to make the best of it...for town and for myself....but sometimes life hands one lemons and no sugar.
(Also more replies to you below)
---------------------
Additional posts....I messed up on quote tags so had to redo it this way:
(replied to Catte and Nmillar)
@Catte Post 387: I didn't want to risk being NKd on N1 if we don't have a protective role to protect me(if scum decided to go after me on N1). Partially because I want to help town, but also because I didn't want to get NKd and be out so early....as I like the game, and all.
Also to be fair I never claimed "normal" PGO.....it's just I withheld the modifier. If people had asked if I had a modifier I would've admitted it then but said I was keeping it hidden for the time being. But no one asked(barring NMillar who sort of asked).
@Catte Post 391: I meant the NK in general....also as many likely know I am ok with(even if others likely dislike such tactics) some small amounts of lying as town if it'll give town or me an edge.
-----------------------
@NMillar Post 389: Maybe....I forget atm(so many topics coming up atm and I didn't take as many notes as I should've).

my name is catte
i touch your foods
Registered: Mar 2010
From United Kingdom

GymHenson
Dearest of all my friends
Registered: Apr 2020
From United States

GymHenson
Dearest of all my friends
Registered: Apr 2020
From United States
Posted August 12, 2020
Note to everyone:
If I somehow survive D1 and don't get lynched, town has to make a tough choice.
They can(if anyone has such a PR) protect me and/or investigate me.....but that would keep such PRs from looking for scum in other players and/or protecting more competent town players.
That said, if we have such PRs, i'd be ok with taking one for the team re: being NKd if it can help town somehow.
If I somehow survive D1 and don't get lynched, town has to make a tough choice.
They can(if anyone has such a PR) protect me and/or investigate me.....but that would keep such PRs from looking for scum in other players and/or protecting more competent town players.
That said, if we have such PRs, i'd be ok with taking one for the team re: being NKd if it can help town somehow.

Vitek
Master of Karate and friendship for everyone
Registered: Apr 2009
From British Indian Ocean Territory

GymHenson
Dearest of all my friends
Registered: Apr 2020
From United States

Vitek
Master of Karate and friendship for everyone
Registered: Apr 2009
From British Indian Ocean Territory

ZFR
I love gold!
Registered: Jan 2010
From Ireland
Posted August 12, 2020
I'll revote Gym before deadline if necessary. Either way he feels more of a liability now

my name is catte
i touch your foods
Registered: Mar 2010
From United Kingdom
Posted August 12, 2020
That's pretty much the point I was making in 370, and that was before the realisation that the whole novice thing completely messes up the earlier explanations for some of the things he did. If we don't embarrass him now, he'll just be this giant unresolvable question mark for the rest of the game.