Ultimate General: Civil War

已在库内

4.4/5

( 79 Reviews )

4.4

79 Reviews

中文(简体), English & 6 更多

最有用的评论

Posted on: February 23, 2018

Atermi

游戏: 256 评论: 7

An essential strategy game

This is THE ultimate wargame. While it doesn't have a strategic overworld, it consists of a historical sequence of large named battles of dozens of thousands troops, plus small unnamed battles in between. The troop formations realistically cover most of the battlefield, giving little space to maneur, but maneuring is essential for the win. Sometimes you have to send your wings into the long raids to attack enemy from behind after 30 IRL minutes. You have 4 types of troops to choose: line infantry, skirmishers, cavalry and artillery. You can give whatever weapons you can get to your troops: from muskets to carbines, impacting on their shooting speed and distance, bayonet melee ability. The battles are staged to reflect every historical detail, like the exact time of reinforcements arrival or enemy counterattack. The game is very educational, too; I am a European who only knew that North and South fought for their opinion on slaves question; now I studied tons of articles and books on the American Civil War thanks to all the realistic historical details, troop and battle names, commanders, etc. This game is VERY user friendly, very convenient to control and view the battlefield; also gives you detailed statistics on losses/casualties/wounded/captured after battle. It plays and looks way better than Take Command or Scourge of War. Also if you played UG: Gettysburgh before, that game was rather a demo of ONE OF OVER 20 historical battles in this game. I greatly recommend this game to every fan of history and/or really strong strategy games. 10/10 in its genre. I hope my review was helpful, and sorry for my English.

这对您有帮助吗？

Posted on: February 25, 2018

babaykal

验证所有者

游戏: 412 评论: 1

The best Civil War game I have played

An incredible game. The negatives first: Some historical inaccuracies, CSA campaign ends very abruptly, broken units regroup too easily, difficulty spikes can be pretty hefty. Very detailed, fun to play, and manages to avoid becoming a "force concentration simulator". Thousands of troops, represented by smaller numbers of models, go at each other, with deep mechanics and difficult choices to make. You need manpower to recruit, but you need money to arm your soldiers. Resource management and getting the right equipment is key. If you carelessly get your men killed, you'll find yourself unable to field an army later. You can ask your government for additional supplies, but that lowers your standing with them and lowers troop morale. Morale is very important; wavering units can barely fight. Units can reform easily after being routed, but after taking too many losses (about 80%), they "shatter" and you lose the entire unit. WIll you use your depleted veterans to capture that strategic piece of cover, or will you save them to fight another day? Oh, and Lincoln/Davis is watching. Make one mistake too many and it's game over. Artillery is nicely detailed: Heavy short range guns devastate enemy charges while longer ranged guns silence enemy artillery and harass their units from afar. You can't just spam cavalry; they have no cover and will get shattered instantly if they try to attack an unengaged enemy unit. The sides are genuinely unique, with the Union getting more money and manpower while the Confederacy gets recruits with higher veterancy. Playing as the Union is somewhat easy, as you get so many toys and the best artillery, your men can gain experience on the fly and become unstoppable with their superior equipment. Playing as the Confederacy is a real challenge, as not only do you have to defend (or sometimes even attack) against superior numbers, but you also cannot afford heavy casualties. A must have for any history geek, Civil War aficionado or strategy gamer.

这对您有帮助吗？

Posted on: July 27, 2018

backsdrummer

验证所有者

游戏: 19 评论: 1

Mostly good but with a couple of flaws

A good game that mostly succeeds in making the player feel like a Civil War general but has a couple of flaws. There is much to commend. As a player you will have to keep an eye on the position and condition of your troops and you usually want to keep a reserve to be ready for sudden changes of fortune. The various types of troops (infantry, skirmishers, artillery, cavalry) all have been given realistic battlefield abilities. Historically successful tactics work well in the game, and the graphics and sound definitely entertaining and put a player in the right mindset. Where the game is not good is when units lose morale. Routed and shattered units should be highly vulnerable and always retreat but instead they become invulnerable and if surrounded they often advance. I've repeatedly seen large routed brigades that were surrounded advance right through one of the formed enemy brigades that defeated them which should never happen. Afterwards the routed brigade reforms in the rear of their enemy. This highly unrealistic feature results is battles becoming a series of scattered minor actions with units facing in every direction because enemies are on all sides. Also, I have a real problem with the Battle of Shiloh scenario. When I played the Confederates captured Pittsburg Landing on the first day and held it against all counterattacks. I had two divisions defending Pittsburg Landing. Then when the day ended the game magically moved the entire Confederate Army a mile or two to the south and put Grant's army on Pittsburg Landing. I got the message that incredibly I did not actually capture Pittsburg Landing even though the 'flag' at that location was Confederate. RIDICULOUS!

这对您有帮助吗？

Posted on: February 28, 2018

alexcres

验证所有者

游戏: 198 评论: 2

Best "Total War" Type of Game

Overall: - this game is all about capture/hold objectives with a timer, not about eliminate ememy forces. - Had great time. I can see myself spend hundreads of hours in this game in the future. Pros: - Really clean pleasant UI. - Good music, sound effect. - Amazing campaign, army management. - Like the tacitical aspect. For most part, just deploy your army, let them do their thing. Cons: - AI is not that smart, small skirmisher in the woods can delay largy ememy forces for a long time and make the game like cake walk. - Skirmishers are king, they are too effective on flank/rear and delay. They are micro intensive, which means if you are doing lots of micro you are going to win way big. - No topography view, please bring 'M' key back. - lots of things are not well explained or not explained at all. Spend some time in forum is highly recommonded. Still nobody knows what supply is, how much should one bring.

这对您有帮助吗？

Posted on: July 4, 2020

Ledunk

验证所有者

游戏: 104 评论: 4

Dragged down by Scaling Enemies

The core game itself is alright, the real draw to the game though is sadly drawn back by it though. You can play the campaign with a persistant army which gains experience and salvages guns, you get money and recruits alotted to you which you can use to expand your army and outfit them. Problem is the game constantly scales the enemy to you creating near impossible scenarios except by doing the constant issue in strategy games of exploiting them. It is to the point where it becomes frustrating and unrewarding almost making army manament completely pointless thanks to the game just countering you by providing the enemy ai with more people and gear for upgrading your army.

这对您有帮助吗？

...

用户评论

出错，请尝试刷新页面。

This game is waiting for a review. Take the first shot!

{{ item.percentage }}%

Awaiting more reviews

An error occurred. Please try again later.

Other ratings

Add a review

Edit a review

Your rating:

Stars and all fields are required

Not sure what to say? Start with this:

What kept you playing?
What kind of gamer would enjoy this?
Was the game fair, tough, or just right?
What’s one feature that really stood out?
Did the game run well on your setup?

不当内容。您的评论包含不良语言。不当内容。不允许使用链接。不当内容。内容包含乱码。评论标题太短。评论标题太长。评论描述太短。评论描述太长。

不知道该写什么？

由于以下原因，您无法保存您的评论:

您需要选择星级评分
您需要输入评论标题
您需要输入您的评论内容

筛选：

没有与您的要求相匹配的评论

English Deutsch polski français русский 中文(简体) 其他人

已验证所有者其他人

最近30天最近90天最近6月任何时间

发售后早期访问期间

探索 CD PROJEKT RED 的游戏

精选

Featured

接近，但不是完全匹配

Ultimate General: Civil War

Other ratings

Add a review

Edit a review

Delete this review?

举报此评价

其他详情（必填）：

举报此评价